Our readers keep the lights on and the coffee maker working hard! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Cold cream does two jobs in one jar: it dissolves makeup and leaves your skin feeling soft instead of stripped. The real question is which formula suits your routine — a deep cleanser that melts waterproof mascara, or a rich hydrator you layer under makeup. This guide breaks down the two POND’S classics that dominate this space, so you can pick the one that fits how you actually wash your face.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Find the right cold cream by weighing makeup removal against daily hydration, with every spec and owner insight laid out for a fast decision.
Quick Picks
- POND’S Cold Cream Make-Up Remover — Best Overall
- POND’S Dry Skin Cream — Premium Pick
How To Choose The Best Cold Cream
Cold cream cleanses without foaming, using a rich, balmy texture that blends oil and water to lift makeup while adding moisture to dry skin. Before you pick one, decide if you need a dedicated makeup remover or a daily moisturizer—this guide helps you tell the difference.
Cleanser or moisturizer, or both?
The two POND’S staples here split the difference. The classic Cold Cream is built around removing stubborn makeup, while the Dry Skin Cream focuses on deep hydration for every day. Choose based on your biggest problem: end-of-day makeup that resists your current cleanser points to the remover, while tight, flaky skin in the morning points to the moisturizer.
Why non-comedogenic matters
Both formulas carry the non-comedogenic label, which means they are designed not to clog your pores. This matters because rich creams often feel heavy, and the wrong one can trigger breakouts. A non-comedogenic cold cream gives you the moisture without the pore-blocking worry, making it a safer bet for combination or acne-prone skin.
Fragrance: a personal call
Fragrance is where opinions split. One of these picks is explicitly fragrance-free, while the other has a scent that owners describe as fresh rather than sticky. If your skin reacts to perfumes, the fragrance-free route removes that variable entirely. If scent is part of the ritual for you, the lightly fragranced option keeps that comfort.
Quick Comparison
In‑Depth Reviews
1. POND’S Cold Cream Make-Up Remover
The makeup-melting classic that treats aging skin and waterproof mascara with equal care.
This is the pick for anyone whose evening routine starts with stubborn makeup. It dissolves all traces of waterproof makeup without drying your skin, which is exactly what owners praise most — makeup removal draws the most positive comments. The formula blends oil and water so it replenishes moisture while it cleans, leaving skin softer and smoother instead of tight.
Unlike a standard cleanser, this one claims to be 50% moisturizer, so half of what you apply is hydration. A little goes a long way, and buyers report it removes eye makeup “easier than anything else I’ve used and that goes for waterproof or non waterproof makeup.” It targets sensitive skin, with hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested labels, plus a non-comedogenic promise (won’t clog pores).
This 2-pack gives you two 6.1 oz jars, which is a 50% more gap in jar count versus the 3-pack dry skin cream below — more product per purchase for the same effort. Gentleness on skin is the second most-discussed win, and owners echo that it leaves skin soft. The one mixed note is fragrance: the jar is labeled fragrance-free, yet a few buyers swear they can smell something, so treat that claim with a light touch if you are extremely scent-sensitive.
What wins people over
- easy removal of stubborn, waterproof makeup
- Doubles as a moisturizer with its 50% formula
- Gentle enough for aging and sensitive skin
Worth knowing
- A few buyers detect a scent despite the fragrance-free label
- Rich texture may feel heavy if you prefer foaming washes
Reach for this if: you battle waterproof makeup at night and want one step that cleans and hydrates, even on sensitive skin.
Look elsewhere if: you want a plain daily moisturizer — that is the job of the Dry Skin Cream.
2. POND’S Dry Skin Cream
The rich daily hydrator that goes on light and never greasy, loved as a makeup base.
This is the everyday moisturizer half of the cold cream story, built for dry skin needing deep hydration from morning to night. Effectiveness leads the owner conversation by a wide margin, with moisturizing a strong second — the two top praises align with its core promise. The texture earns the raves: it applies light, absorbs quickly, and leaves skin soft without any greasy film.
Its standout real-world use is as a makeup base. Owners mention using it “everyday as the base for my makeup and my skin has been amazing,” and a 67-year-old says it leaves “the most youthful beautiful skin you’ve likely seen.” It locks in moisture and supports natural radiance, working as an AM and PM step after cleansing.
This 3-pack of 10.1 oz jars — one more jar than the remover’s 2-pack — signals a longer shelf life for the daily routine, and owners confirm it lasts a long time. Dermatologist-tested and hypoallergenic, it also carries the non-comedogenic label so it won’t strip natural moisture or clog pores. The honest caveat: while most customers note no irritation, a smaller number mention itching, so patch-test first if your skin reacts easily. The scent reads fresh to most, not sticky, which is the opposite of the fragrance-free remover.
The daily-driver read: if you want one rich, non-greasy moisturizer that sits beautifully under makeup, this is the crowd favorite with the most owner history behind it.
The trade-off: it hydrates rather than removes, so you still need a cleanser like the Cold Cream above for end-of-day makeup.
Best for: dry or sensitive skin looking for deep, lasting hydration morning and night.
Not for: anyone expecting a makeup remover — that job belongs to the fragrance-free Cold Cream.
Understanding the Specs
The 50% moisturizer formula
This is the number that separates cold cream from ordinary cleansers. Half of the formula is moisturizer, so it cleans and hydrates in a single step. Normal foaming washes strip oil and leave skin tight; this blend replaces moisture while it lifts makeup, which is why skin feels soft instead of pulled.
Non-comedogenic and hypoallergenic
Non-comedogenic means the formula is designed to not clog your pores, which is the usual fear with rich creams. Hypoallergenic points to a lower chance of triggering allergic reactions, and dermatologist-tested signals it has been checked by skin experts. Together they make a thick cream safe for sensitive and breakout-prone skin.
FAQ
Can I use cold cream every day?
Will cold cream clog my pores?
Is the Make-Up Remover truly fragrance-free?
Does the Dry Skin Cream work under makeup?
Which one removes waterproof mascara better?
How long does a pack last?
Is the Dry Skin Cream good for sensitive skin?
Can I use cold cream if I have acne?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For the majority of shoppers, the cold cream winner is the POND’S Cold Cream Make-Up Remover because it handles the hardest job — melting waterproof makeup — while still moisturizing, and its fragrance-free formula suits the widest range of skin. If you want deep daily hydration that sits light under makeup, grab the POND’S Dry Skin Cream. And if your evenings are the problem, the remover’s 50% moisturizer blend makes the clean-and-hydrate routine a single step.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of August 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gardening Beyond earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.