Our readers keep the lights on and the coffee maker working hard! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
If you are reading this standing up because sitting hurts, you want a cream that numbs the burning and stinging within minutes, not next week. Below are nine external creams and ointments for hemorrhoid pain, sorted by what actually matters — the numbing ingredient and how strong it is, how thick the formula is, and whether it comes as a single tube or a multi-pack you can keep in two bathrooms. The two worth your money come first: a 1% dibucaine ointment that holds up to 8 hours per application, and a 20% benzocaine ointment with the most owner reviews on this list.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Every pick here is an external-use product with a real numbing or soothing active ingredient, so you are choosing between strengths and textures rather than guessing. Here is how to pick the best cream for hemorrhoid pain by reading the active ingredient and its percentage before you buy.
Our Picks at a Glance
How To Choose The Best Cream For Hemorrhoid Pain
Most people grab the tube with the biggest name on it and end up with something that soothes but never actually numbs. The fix is to look at two lines on the back of the box before anything else — the active ingredient with its percentage, and how often you are allowed to apply it.
Start with the active numbing ingredient, not the brand
Dibucaine 1% is a topical anesthetic, which is a numbing agent you rub on the skin. It works fast and, in a dibucaine formula, a single application can hold for up to 8 hours. Benzocaine at 20% is a much stronger concentration of a different numbing agent, and it hits hard and fast. Lidocaine 5% is the strongest numbing agent you can get without a prescription, so it is the ceiling for over-the-counter relief. Pramoxine, used in Tronolane, is a gentler anesthetic paired with zinc oxide, an astringent that tightens and dries irritated tissue. The right one depends on whether you are chasing deep pain or surface itch and burning.
Then decide how thick you want the formula
Thickness is not a marketing word here; it decides whether the cream stays put. Buyers of the GeriCare ointment split on this exact point — the effectiveness is what wins people over, but a chunk of owners find it extremely thick. Thick ointments coat and protect but can feel heavy. Greaseless creams like Tronolane skip the mess and the staining but sit lighter. If you are applying before work, a greaseless, odorless formula matters more than raw strength. If you are applying at night and sleeping on it, a heavy ointment that stays in place is the better call.
Count the tubes before you count the pennies
A hemorrhoid flare-up rarely ends after one tube. Two-packs and three-packs let you leave one in each bathroom, one in a bag, and one in a first-aid kit, which is exactly what these formulas are designed for — one pick here is explicitly sold as two tubes so you always have a spare. You also want to check the age floor: several of these are labeled suitable for kids 12 and up, which matters if you are buying for a household rather than just yourself. And check the cap and closure, because a handful of owner notes across these listings mention caps that are hard to open or tubes that leak before they are half used.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Active Ingredient | Format | Age Floor | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GeriCare Dibucaine Hemorroid Ointment★ Best Overall | All-day numbing on a budget | Dibucaine 1% | 2 x 1 oz tubes | 12+ | Amazon |
| Rugby Dibucaine Topical Anesthetic 1%Best Value | Dull pain and insect-bite itch | Dibucaine 1% | 2 x 1 oz tubes | 12+ | Amazon |
| Americaine Hemorrhoidal Ointment Maximum StrengthStrongest Formula | Fast, hard numbing | Benzocaine 20% | 2 x 1 oz tubes | — | Amazon |
| Tronolane Dual Action Anesthetic Cream | Clean, greaseless daily use | Pramoxine HCl + Zinc Oxide | 1 oz tube | — | Amazon |
| Globe RectaEase Lidocaine 5% | Stocking every bathroom | Lidocaine 5% | 3 x 1 oz tubes | — | Amazon |
| Rrhoid Rage Hemorrhoid Ointment | Itching, burning and fissures | Lidocaine + witch hazel + aloe | 1 oz tube | — | Amazon |
| Megababe Hemorrhoidal Ointment | Whole-symptom relief in one tube | Lidocaine 5% + Phenylephrine | 1.25 oz tube | — | Amazon |
| Ebanel 5% Lidocaine Hemorrhoid Treatment Cream | Shrinking and repairing | Lidocaine 5% + Phenylephrine HCl 0.25% | 1 oz tube | — | Amazon |
| DERMATOOL Advanced Hemorrhoid Cream | Swelling reduction with a guarantee | Lidocaine 5% + Phenylephrine | 1 oz tube | — | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. GeriCare Dibucaine Hemorroid Ointment 1% Pain-Relief Hemorrhoid Cream (2 Pack)
Our pick — over 4.5★ from 500+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
Eight hours of quiet, from one small squeeze of a 1% dibucaine tube.
The number that decides this pick is 8 — a single application of this dibucaine ointment is built to hold for up to 8 hours. That is the difference between numbing up before a workday and re-applying in a restroom stall at lunch. Dibucaine is a topical anesthetic, a numbing agent you rub onto the skin, and at 1% it goes to work quickly on burning and itching around the anal area. GeriCare labels it for external use only, so it is not for internal application, and it is sold as two 1 oz tubes so one can live in a bag or first-aid kit while the other stays home.
The package says it is suitable for kids 12 and up, which is rare in this category and useful for a household rather than a single person. The other reason this ranks first is what owners say about it: effectiveness is easily the most-discussed point on the listing, with pain relief close behind, and the review pages read like a short relief diary — “it really does work” and “worked well. No pain.” The 2-pack also answers the practical problem of a flare-up that returns, because a second tube means you are never caught out mid-week.
Here is the honest catch, and it is a texture one rather than a strength one. This is a thick ointment, and thickness is the single mixed note in the feedback — several owners describe it as extremely thick. That heaviness is what keeps it where you put it, but if you hate a heavy film, a greaseless formula will suit you better. The child-resistant cap and child-resistant packaging are a plus, though if your hands are sore, expect a little extra effort to open it.
What earns it the top slot
- One application is designed to last up to 8 hours, so it covers a full workday
- Two 1 oz tubes per order — keep one home and one packed
- Labeled suitable for kids 12 and up, which few dibucaine ointments state
- Works on burning, itching and discomfort rather than just one symptom
What to know before you buy
- External use only — the maker states it is not safe for internal use
- The formula is noticeably thick, which is the one point owners disagree on
- Child-resistant packaging takes a moment to open when you are sore
Reach for this if: you want one application to cover a long stretch of the day and you do not mind a thick ointment doing the work.
Look elsewhere if: you need internal use or you want a greaseless, invisible finish — the Tronolane cream below is the cleaner-textured alternative.
2. Rugby Dibucaine Topical Anesthetic 1% Hemorrhoid Ointment (2-Pack)
Same 1% dibucaine strength, but it spreads like a cream instead of a salve.
If the thickness of the GeriCare puts you off, Rugby is the answer to that exact complaint at the same 1% dibucaine strength. Owners describe it as a soft, spreadable translucent ointment, and the review pages sum it up: “Works great to dull the pain of hemorrhoids and reduce the itching of insect bites.” That dual use is worth knowing — this one earns its place in the medicine cabinet for bites and skin irritation, not only for flare-ups. You get two 1 oz tubes, and it is labeled for adults and children 12 and up.
This formula is also associated with sensitive-skin use in a way most don’t manage. Buyers report using a dibucaine 1% ointment before and after anal-area treatment, where it applied gently, took only minutes to work, and produced a slight tingle before the relief arrived. It has shown up in post-treatment skin care too, with one buyer describing exactly that kind of raw, red skin. Note the practical limit: one tube’s cap was reported as extremely difficult to remove, hard enough that the tube had to be cut open, so treat the closure gently rather than yanking it.
Where it wins: spreadable texture, double duty for bites and irritation, and two tubes per order.
Where it asks for care: the cap on a tube can be stiff — twist slowly rather than forcing it.
Take this one if: you want dibucaine’s quick numbing in a softer, easier-spreading base than a heavy salve.
skip it if: you need a sealed, screw-free closure or a formula labeled for use inside the canal.
3. Americaine Hemorrhoidal Ointment Maximum Strength 20% Benzocaine (Pack of 2)
Twenty percent benzocaine — the heaviest numbing punch in this whole lineup.
The relief reports are unusually specific. Owners mention using this after Preparation H and suppositories failed, and describe a hemorrhoid going “from a raisin to 1/3 of the size” in a single day, with repeat users saying they get numbing that lasts a reasonable stretch. It has also been used for pain and itch on skin elsewhere on the body, which tells you how reliably it numbs. Weigh that against the two things owners flag: excess application can numb surrounding genital skin too, so a little goes a long way, and the tubes have a track record of developing leaks before they are half empty, which makes for messy application. Keep the cap tight and store it upright.
One scale note if you are comparing by size: this two-pack is listed at 6 x 6 x 10 inches and 1.6 ounces, while the Tronolane single tube is 1 x 1 x 4 inches and 0.96 ounces — a genuinely larger package on the shelf, so plan your drawer space accordingly.
Why people reach for it
- 20% benzocaine is the strongest numbing concentration on this list
- Two 1 oz tubes, so you always have a spare when a flare-up drags on
- Customers note it numbing well and lasting a reasonable time per application
- Fast enough that it has been used for sharp, crying-level pain
The trade-offs to plan around
- Applying too much can numb nearby genital skin, so start with a small amount
- Tubes have been known to leak before they are half used — store upright
- Opinions on overall comfort are mixed even though the numbing itself is praised
This is your tube if: gentler creams have not touched the pain and you want the hardest numbing an over-the-counter product allows.
Think twice if: you want a light, quick-absorbing film — this one is an ointment, and it is meant to be used sparingly.
4. Tronolane Dual Action Anesthetic Cream For Hemorrhoids (1 Oz)
A greaseless, stainless cream you can apply and then walk out the door.
Tronolane solves the problem the ointments create. It is a greaseless, stainless, odorless cream, so there is no petroleum film in your underwear and no smell to worry about, which makes it the easiest of the lot to use on a work morning. The formula is dual action: pramoxine hydrochloride is the numbing agent, and zinc oxide is an astringent that tightens and dries irritated tissue. At 0.96 ounces and roughly 1 x 1 x 4 inches, it is the most compact tube here — small enough to slip into a jacket pocket, and noticeably lighter than the Americaine two-pack.
What divides people is not whether it numbs but what it numbs. Pain relief is overwhelmingly the top talking point on this listing, and the relief in one report arrived within 1–2 hours on severe pain following chemo-related diarrhea. But read the fine print honestly: it soothes pain and irritation and does not reduce swelling or stop bleeding, and it is not a numbing-heavy formula — one owner who expected a strong numbing effect only found pain and burning relief. Some buyers find it greaseless and comfortable; a smaller group finds the texture and the value mixed, and a few note a burning sensation on application. It wipes clean and does not stain clothes, and it is one of the few here with no unpleasant odor at all.
The right pick for: anyone who wants discreet, no-mess, no-smell relief for pain and itching they can apply before leaving the house.
Not the right pick for: reducing swelling or stopping bleeding, or deep numbing — for that, step up to a 5% lidocaine cream.
5. Globe RectaEase Lidocaine 5% Hemorrhoid Cream, 3 Pack
Three tubes, three bathrooms, and the strongest numbing strength sold without a prescription.
RectaEase answers a simple logistical question: how do you make sure a tube is always within arm’s reach? Three of them. It is a 5% lidocaine cream, and 5% is the maximum over-the-counter strength of lidocaine, the strongest numbing agent you can buy without a prescription. The formula is designed to desensitize the aggravated nerves on and around the anus, which is what turns off the pain, itching and burning rather than just coating them. Each tube is 1 oz and compact enough for a travel bag or first-aid kit.
The maker also cites lidocaine’s use by physicians for topical relief since 1948, a Domestic Drug Code listing, and manufacturing at US-audited facilities. In practice, owners describe a cream that absorbs quickly and lets them sit and travel longer than they could otherwise. The one recurring texture gripe is that it does not fully absorb for everyone, leaving a slightly sticky residue that can mark clothing, so wear something you would not mind staining until it settles. This 3-pack is listed at 3 ounces total, notably heavier than the 1 oz single tubes elsewhere on this page.
What it nails: maximum OTC numbing strength in the biggest tube count here, so you can outfit every bathroom in the house.
What to watch: that sticky residue — a light application absorbs better than a generous one.
Best suited to: a household that wants maximum-strength lidocaine in every bathroom and travel bag without reordering every few weeks.
Not your tube if: you dislike any residue on skin — a greaseless formula like Tronolane above will feel cleaner.
6. Rrhoid Rage Hemorrhoid Ointment with Lidocaine, Aloe, Magnesium Sulfate and Balsam Fir
Built for the tears as much as the bumps — fissures get equal billing here.
Most creams quietly admit they are only for hemorrhoids. This one names fissures — small tears in the anal lining — in the product name itself, alongside hemorrhoids and piles. The formula stacks lidocaine for numbing with witch hazel, aloe and magnesium for soothing a much wider patch of angry tissue. It is made in Miami, USA by a veteran-owned company, and it is meant to form a protective shield that calms inflammation and stops itching in its tracks. Effect is the headline here: swelling reduction and comfort, not just numbing.
What owners keep coming back to is how fast the visible stuff changes. Reviewers point out external hemorrhoid and internal fissure swelling dropping by day one and being gone by day three, and one describes a hemorrhoid shrinking to half a tic-tac in size, with pain during bowel movements gone entirely. The texture is worth knowing before you squeeze: owners describe it as Vaseline-like and thick but not greasy, meaning it coats without sliding off. It is odorless, which matters if you apply it before work, and the review pages genuinely enjoy the humor in the name.
The honest trade-off is money. Value for money is the single mixed theme in the feedback, and the tub is a 1 oz tube, so heavy users will finish it faster than the multi-packs. Bottle size is another smaller mixed note. If you are a fissure sufferer who has burned through tube after tube of cream, that is exactly the scenario this pick is built for.
Choose this if: fissures are part of your picture, not just hemorrhoids — the formula is aimed squarely at both.
Look at the multi-packs if: you expect to use it daily for weeks, since this is a single 1 oz tube.
7. Megababe Hemorrhoidal Ointment, Max Strength Rapid 5% Lidocaine, 1.25 oz
The one tube that treats the pain, the itch and the swelling at the same time.
Megababe’s pitch is breadth — a single 1.25 oz tube covers everything at once. It runs two actives: 5% lidocaine, the maximum over-the-counter numbing strength, to handle pain and itch, and phenylephrine to reduce swelling and inflammation. Underneath that sit cocoa butter, glycerin and petrolatum to protect sensitive tissue, aloe and calendula to calm and hydrate, and colloidal oatmeal to support a healthy skin barrier. It is free of fragrance, parabens, sulfates and phthalates, and it is Leaping Bunny certified, so it is one of the gentler-feeling options here despite sitting at the top of the numbing scale. The maker says it can be used up to 4 times daily.
The texture is what converts doubters. Owners describe it as not too greasy, with a small amount going a long way, and the numbing arriving almost instantly. It is also cited for lasting a long time and for helping shrink swelling — one buyer reports theirs were gone inside two weeks. The foil is packaging and price. A chunk of feedback calls the value mixed, with one owner calling it a “pink tax” product not obviously better than drugstore brands and declining to repurchase on cost alone. So take it at face value: you are paying extra for a clean formula, great ingredients and a tube you would not mind leaving on the counter — not for a stronger numbing agent than a cheaper 5% cream.
What it brings to the shelf
- Two actives in one tube — 5% lidocaine for pain and itch plus phenylephrine for swelling
- Botanical base with aloe, calendula and colloidal oatmeal to calm irritated skin
- Fragrance-free, sulfate-free, and Leaping Bunny certified
- Shoppers say a small dab goes a long way and numbs almost instantly
Where it edges over budget
- Value for money is the recurring mixed note — it is priced well above the ingredient-matched creams
- At 1.25 oz, it is a single tube rather than a multi-pack
- If you only want numbing and do not care about a clean botanical base, the cheaper 5% lids do the same job
This one is for you if: you want pain, itch and swelling handled together and you care about what else is in the tube.
pass on it if: you are shopping on price alone — a plain 5% lidocaine cream numbs just as hard for less.
8. Ebanel 5% Lidocaine Hemorrhoid Treatment Cream
The formula with the biggest owner base — and the cooling bottom line, for short.
Ebanel’s cream runs on a pair of actives: 5% lidocaine to numb, and phenylephrine HCl at 0.25% to shrink dilated tissue. That second ingredient is the one that separates the “shrinking” family from the pure-anesthetic creams here, since phenylephrine reduces swelling rather than just deadening pain. Beyond the actives, it stacks witch hazel, horse chestnut, centella asiatica and myrtle oil — a botanical lineup aimed at reducing irritation and bleeding, and said to help with inflamed anal tissue, fissures and pregnancy-related piles. It also adds zinc oxide, frankincense, green tea and chamomile to form a protective barrier over torn, inflamed skin, plus Vitamin B5, Vitamin E, coconut oil, argan oil and petrolatum to lubricate and coat. It is made in the USA in an FDA-registered facility, cruelty-free, cGMP certified, hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic, and it comes with three applicators and a child-resistant cap.
Where buyers notice it most is on the swelling and the ring of pain. Buyers report a hemorrhoid that had prolapsed for years staying in after a single push following two days of use, after other creams did nothing. Another describes crying-level pain and poor sleep turning around quickly, with the cream healing better than thinner, waterier options — with the honest caveat that it wears off quickly and the price is high. Two things worth knowing: the formula is thick and stays put once applied, which is what makes it last, and a small number of buyers have found it irritates their skin, so patch-test if your skin is sensitive.
Why it earns its place: the deepest foliage list on the page — anti-inflammatory, barrier-forming and lubricating ingredients in a single tube.
The honest warning: it can be irritating to some skin, and the effect wears off faster than you may expect from a thick cream.
Best for: prolapsed or swelling-prone hemorrhoids, and anyone who wants the soothing, healing side of the ingredients list, not just the numbing.
Not ideal for: sensitive skin that reacts to strong formulas, or anyone wanting a light, fast-absorbing finish.
9. DERMATOOL Advanced Hemorrhoid Cream 5% Lidocaine & Phenylephrine
Four actives, a fast-shrinking formula, and an empty-tube money-back promise.
DERMATOOL stacks four active ingredients into one tube — 5% lidocaine to numb and phenylephrine to shrink — plus witch hazel, aloe, Vitamin E and horse chestnut in the supporting formula. The pitch is blunt: rapid relief that reduces swelling and quiets pain, aimed at both men and women, and made in the USA. Where it stands apart from the others is the guarantee. It carries a 100% empty-tube money-back promise — if it does not work for you, the maker says no questions asked, and they will refund you even if you have used the whole thing. That removes most of the risk of trying a formula you are unsure about.
Swelling and sleep are the two things owners single out. One buyer reports swelling improving a lot with no skin irritation and no smell or sticky petroleum feel, calling it better than the name brand from the pharmacy. Another describes using it over a few days with major positive results, and a third points to quick pain relief that let them sleep more soundly — a real-world benefit for anyone who has lost nights to this. It is also a lighter-textured cream than the Ebanel, so it will not leave a heavy film behind, though it is still a focused single-symptom formula rather than a full botanical repair cream.
Good for you if: you want swelling reduction and a guarantee that lets you try it without risk.
Look instead to Ebanel if: you want the wider botanical repair-and-lubricate formula alongside the numbing and shrinking actives.
Understanding the Specs
Active Ingredient and Strength
Every cream here is judged first on two numbers: the active ingredient and its percentage. Dibucaine at 1% is a fast-working topical anesthetic, and one dibucaine formula is built to hold for up to 8 hours per application. Benzocaine at 20% is the hardest numbing punch in this group — much more concentrated than the others, so a little goes a long way. Lidocaine at 5% is the ceiling for over-the-counter numbing power, so any 5% lidocaine cream sits at the top of what you can buy without a prescription. Pramoxine, used in Tronolane, is a gentler anesthetic paired with zinc oxide, which is an astringent that tightens and dries irritated tissue. If you want to shrink swelling rather than just deaden pain, look for phenylephrine on the label alongside the numbing agent. Each ingredient is a different tool: dibucaine for hours of coverage, benzocaine for hard surface numbing, lidocaine for maximum OTC strength, pramoxine for gentler relief.
Texture and Format
The other spec that decides how you will actually use the tube is texture. Greaseless, stainless creams like Tronolane go on clean and leave no film or smell, which makes them the easy pick before work or travel. Thick ointments coat better and stay where you put them through long stretches, which is exactly why they can hold for hours, but heavy texture is the one point owners argue about most. Expect a heavily thick formula to feel substantial rather than invisible. Format matters too: a 1 oz tube is small enough for a pocket, while a 2-pack or 3-pack lets you leave a tube in every bathroom and your bag. Also check the age floor — some are labeled suitable for kids 12 and up — and whether you get applicators for cleaner application.
FAQ
Which numbing ingredient is best for hemorrhoid pain?
How long does a hemorrhoid cream take to work?
Can I use these creams internally?
Is 5% lidocaine stronger than 1% dibucaine or 20% benzocaine?
Do any of these creams shrink hemorrhoids or reduce swelling?
How long does one tube last and should I buy a multi-pack?
Can I use these creams on children?
Why do some people find these creams too thick or too greasy?
Do these creams stain or smell?
Do these creams work for fissures and not just hemorrhoids?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
If you want one tube that covers a full workday of pain and itching without re-applying at lunch, the cream for hemorrhoid pain pick is the GeriCare Dibucaine Hemorroid Ointment — its 1% dibucaine is built to hold up to 8 hours per application, and the two-tube pack means you always have a spare. If the pain is sharp and the gentler ointments have not touched it, reach for the Americaine 20% Benzocaine Ointment, the strongest numbing concentration on this page. And if swelling is your main problem rather than pain, the Ebanel 5% Lidocaine Cream pairs its numbing agent with phenylephrine to shrink the tissue, backed by the largest owner base here at 4.4 stars across 800+ ratings. Buy the formula that matches your worst symptom — deep pain, surface itch, or swelling.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of September 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gardening Beyond earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.