Picking the right party favor is the last detail that leaves the longest impression. A thoughtful favor ties the whole event together and gives guests a tangible memory of the celebration.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. I’ve spent countless hours analyzing customer feedback, comparing ingredient lists and packaging specs, and studying the design trends that make baby shower favors a hit with guests instead of an afterthought.
This guide breaks down the best options by type, guest count, and presentation quality so you can find the perfect thank-you gift. Choosing the right best baby shower favors means finding a balance between usefulness, charm, and budget that truly suits your party.
How To Choose The Best Baby Shower Favors
Baby shower favors serve as a small token of gratitude for guests. The best ones are universally appreciated, fit the party theme, and offer real utility or enjoyment — they shouldn’t just collect dust. Focus on the guest count, the type of favor, and the presentation quality.
Guest Count & Per-Favor Value
The total number of guests directly dictates your budget and which sets work. A 24-pack works for small gatherings, while 60-count sets cover larger showers with room for extras. Pay attention to the per-favor value — a hand cream at a travel size feels more substantial than a single mint, though both are appreciated in different contexts.
Favor Type & Guest Demographics
Edible favors like buttermints are universally safe and nostalgic, while practical items like pens or hand creams offer lasting use. Consider your guest list — a mixed-age crowd often appreciates the timelessness of wrapped mints or the gentle scent of a hand lotion. Avoid overly specific scents or designs that might not appeal to all guests.
Packaging & Presentation
The unboxing experience matters. Organza bags, thank-you tags, and coordinated colors elevate a simple product into a memorable favor. Many sets include these elements, saving you assembly time. Check if you need to cut twine or tie ribbons yourself — some sets require a bit of DIY effort for that rustic look.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AZEN Hand Cream & Lip Balm Set | Premium Combo | Two-in-one gift | 30 creams + 30 lip balms | Amazon |
| VISCOO 60-Pack Hand Cream (Girl) | Cosmetic Bulk | Large guest list | 60 cream tubes + bags + tags | Amazon |
| Oh Baby Hand Lotion Set | Cosmetic Bulk | Neutral theme | 60 cream tubes + eucalyptus design | Amazon |
| Candy Envy Buttermints | Edible | Classic edible favor | 100 individually wrapped mints | Amazon |
| Chuangdi Ballpoint Pens | Practical | Game giveaways | 24 pens / 4 designs | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. AZEN 30 Sets Hand Cream and Lip Balm Bulk Set
This two-in-one set from AZEN combines hand cream and lip balm, creating a more substantial favor than single-item options. The 30-count package includes 30 creams, 30 lip balms, organza bags, and thank-you labels — everything you need for a complete gift without extra shopping. The lip balms come in 10 different flavors (Strawberry, Watermelon, Mango, Coconut, Pineapple, Vanilla, Mint, Grape, Peach, Orange), and the hand creams feature 6 distinct scents like freesia, lily, peach, and grapefruit, offering variety that guests appreciate.
Each item is travel-sized, making them portable and easy to include in gift bags. The included thank-you labels add a personal touch, and you can write custom messages for an extra layer of thoughtfulness. Reviewers consistently mention the packaging quality and the overall value as standout features, with many noting that guests were pleasantly surprised by the dual-product nature of the favor.
While each individual tube is small — typical for bulk favor sets — the combination of two separate items (hand cream and lip balm) makes the gift feel more complete and generous than a single tube alone. The organza bags are white and neutral, fitting any shower theme from pink to green without clashing. This set is also versatile enough for weddings, bridal showers, or church events.
What works
- Two practical items per guest
- 10 lip balm flavors provide variety
- Includes bags and labels for instant assembly
What doesn’t
- Individual tubes are small
- Not specifically themed for baby showers
2. VISCOO 60 Sets Baby Shower Hand Cream Gifts (Girl)
This VISCOO set is engineered for larger baby showers with its 60-piece count, making it one of the most generous bulk options for the price. Each hand cream tube is cherry blossom flavored, and the pink flower design with the golden “Baby Girl” copy ties directly into a girl-themed shower. The set also includes 65 organza bags and 65 thank-you tags — giving you a few extras in case of spills or late RSVPs.
The hand cream formula uses natural plant extracts, shea butter, vitamin E, honey, and aloe vera, providing deep moisturizing without a greasy feel. Travel size makes these easy for guests to slip into a purse or pocket. Reviewers praise the fresh, clean scent and the cute packaging, noting that the lotion feels nice on the skin and doesn’t leave a sticky residue — a common complaint with bulk lotions.
One small assembly detail: the bags and tags come with twine that you’ll need to cut and tie yourself if you want that rustic look. This takes a bit of time for 60 sets but the final presentation is worth it. The scent is described as pleasant and not overwhelming, making it suitable for a wide range of guests, even those sensitive to strong fragrances.
What works
- 60-count covers big parties
- Cherry blossom scent is universally pleasant
- Non-greasy formula absorbs quickly
What doesn’t
- Requires DIY twine cutting for tags
- The “Baby Girl” design limits use for neutral themes
3. Oh Baby 60 Sets Travel Size Hand Lotion
This Oh Baby set is nearly identical in structure to the VISCOO Girl set, but with a key difference: the packaging features green eucalyptus leaves and the elegant gold “Oh Baby” text, making it suitable for neutral or boy-themed showers where pink flowers don’t fit. It includes 60 cherry blossom scented hand creams, 65 organza bags, and 65 thank-you tags — offering the same generous extras as its counterpart.
The formula is identical to the VISCOO set, using natural plant extracts, shea butter, vitamin E, honey, and aloe vera for deep moisturizing. The scent is consistent — fresh, clean cherry blossom — and the non-greasy texture means guests won’t be left with sticky hands after applying. The travel size tubes are compact enough to fit in a wallet or small gift bag without adding bulk.
Reviewers highlight the same pros: cute packaging, great scent, and nice size that doesn’t look cheap. The green and gold color scheme feels more sophisticated than the pink alternative, making this a better choice for gender-neutral or boy showers. As with the other set, expect to spend some time attaching the thank-you tags with the provided twine if you want the full rustic presentation.
What works
- Neutral eucalyptus design fits any theme
- 60-count covers large guest lists
- Non-greasy, fast-absorbing lotion
What doesn’t
- Same DIY tag assembly required
- Scent doesn’t last very long on skin
4. Candy Envy – It’s A Girl Buttermints 13 oz. Bag
When you want a favor that requires zero assembly and is guaranteed to be appreciated, these buttermints from Candy Envy are the ultimate no-fuss choice. The 13-ounce bag contains approximately 100 individually wrapped mints, each wrapped in a wrapper printed with “It’s A Girl” — instantly tying the favor to your shower theme. Buttermints, also known as wedding mints or pillow mints, are a time-honored tradition at celebratory events.
The texture of these mints is notably soft and melt-in-your-mouth, avoiding the hard, chalky consistency that some butter mints suffer from. Reviewers consistently describe them as delicious, soft, and buttery — a hit with guests of all ages. The individually wrapped format means you can place them on tables, add them to gift bags, or put them in a candy buffet for guests to grab as they leave.
The value is strong: at roughly 100 pieces, you can easily serve 20-50 guests with multiple mints each or use them as a standalone favor for a smaller party. The wrappers are pink and feature the “It’s A Girl” text, so this set is best suited for girl-themed showers. For neutral or boy themes, look for the “It’s A Boy” counterpart from the same brand, which offers identical quality in a different color scheme.
What works
- Zero assembly — open bag and serve
- Soft, melt-in-mouth texture
- 100 pieces cover a large crowd
What doesn’t
- Only suitable for girl-themed showers
- Not a lasting keepsake favor
5. Chuangdi 24 Pcs Boy Baby Shower Ballpoint Pens Favors Bulk
These retractable ballpoint pens from Chuangdi are the most practical favor on this list — every guest uses pens, and these double as game giveaways or writing tools for shower activities. The 24-pack features 4 distinct boy-themed designs printed on the barrel: airplanes, baby clothes, clouds, and blue text including phrases like “welcome baby”, “love”, and “It’s a boy!”. The black ink writes smoothly and the retractable mechanism eliminates the need for separate caps.
The pens measure 5.31 inches long and 0.47 inches wide — roughly the size of a standard pen. They include a clip for attaching to pockets, pencil cases, or bags. While the plastic construction is lightweight and portable, some reviewers note that the barrel feels a bit wide and the plastic texture is noticeable compared to higher-end pens. However, the writing quality is praised, with one reviewer calling the ink “beautiful” and noting easy, smooth writing.
These pens are best suited for smaller showers with 24 or fewer guests, or as supplies for games and activities that guests can then take home. The boy-specific designs make them ideal for boy showers, but they could also work for neutral events if the blue-and-white color scheme fits. Consider pairing these with a small candy or mint for a balanced favor that combines utility with a treat.
What works
- Practical, reusable favor with daily use
- 4 different boy-themed designs
- Smooth black ink writes well
What doesn’t
- Plastic barrel feels somewhat bulky
- Only 24 pieces — not enough for large parties
Favor Types & Guest Count Guide
Practical Vs. Edible Favors
Practical favors like hand creams, lip balms, and pens offer lasting utility — guests use them long after the party. Edible favors like buttermints are consumed immediately and offer a nostalgic, feel-good moment. Choose practical favors for mixed-age groups who appreciate functionality, and edible favors for casual, low-pressure gatherings where a sweet gesture is enough.
Count Per Guest
A good rule of thumb is to order one favor per guest plus 5-10 extras for unexpected attendees or gifts for the host. A 24-count set works for parties with 15-20 guests. A 30-count set covers 25-30 guests comfortably. For guest lists of 40-50, the 60-count sets provide plenty of margin. For mints, a bag of 100 pieces can serve 20-30 guests with multiple mints each.
FAQ
How many baby shower favors should I order per guest?
Are edible or practical favors better for baby showers?
Can I use the same favor for a boy shower as a girl shower?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most gardeners, the best baby shower favors winner is the AZEN Hand Cream and Lip Balm Set because it offers two useful items per guest in a complete package with bags and tags, making assembly effortless while providing the highest perceived value. If you want a gender-neutral option for large guest lists, grab the Oh Baby Hand Lotion Set. And for a classic, zero-assembly edible treat that guests of all ages adore, nothing beats the Candy Envy Buttermints.