Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
The promise of a dual compartment trash can sounds simple: one bin for trash, one for recycling, no second can taking up floor space. The reality is that small differences in pedal feel, lid speed, and inner bucket design separate the models you will happily use for years from the ones that will annoy you every single day.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
After sorting through seven models by their actual measured dimensions, step counts, and weight, one clear winner emerged for the dual compartment trash can category.
Quick Picks
- simplehuman Step Recycler, 58L / 15.3 Gallon — Top Performer
- SONGMICS Trash Can, 2 x 8 Gallon (2 x 30 L) — Best Overall
- Lovewind Dual Trash and Recycling Bins — Large Capacity
- GarveeHome 2 x 8 gal Stainless Steel Double — Compact Premium
- Arlopu 16Gal Dual Trash Can w/ 2 Built-in Box — Odor Tamer
- Simpli-Magic 60 Liter / 16 Gallon Dual — Color-Coded
- Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 Gallon — Budget Champion
How To Choose The Best Dual Compartment Trash Can
A dual compartment trash can is not just about having two bins in one frame. The way the pedal connects to the lid, the weight of the lid material, and whether the inner buckets lift out all determine whether this thing works as a daily tool or becomes a frustration.
Pedal durability and step count
The pedal is the single most stressed part. Some manufacturers test their pedal to a specific number of steps — 150,000, 180,000, or 200,000 cycles. A higher number means the hinge and spring are built to last years of daily use without getting loose or breaking.
Soft-close vs slam shut
Soft-close lids use a hydraulic or spring-based motion control to lower the lid gently. Without it, the lid slams every time you step off the pedal — and that noise gets old fast in a kitchen or laundry room.
Inner buckets or liner rim
Some cans use removable inner buckets that lift out with a handle for easy emptying and washing. Others skip the inner bucket and use a liner rim that grips the bag directly, saving space inside the can but making removal slightly less convenient.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Total Capacity | Weight | Pedal Test | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| simplehuman Step Recycler | Premium daily sorting | 15.3 gal (58 L) | 9.66 kg | 150,000 steps | Amazon |
| SONGMICS Double Compartment | Balanced value + build | 16 gal (2 x 8) | 20.4 lb | 180,000 steps | Amazon |
| Lovewind 19+8 Gallon | Large households | 27 gal (72+30 L) | 24.6 lb | 200,000 steps | Amazon |
| GarveeHome 2 x 8 gal | Compact footprint | 16 gal (2 x 8) | 17.58 lb | 150,000+ steps | Amazon |
| Arlopu 16Gal Dual | Built-in odor control | 16 gal (2 x 8) | 23 lb | 200,000+ steps | Amazon |
| Simpli-Magic 60 Liter | Color-coded sorting | 16 gal (60 L) | 15 lb | not specified | Amazon |
| Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 gal | Small space / kids | 11 gal (40 L) | 6 lb | not specified | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. simplehuman Step Recycler, 58L / 15.3 Gallon
The sorting station that hides trash and recycling in one stainless steel footprint.
The simplehuman Step Recycler is built differently from every other can on this list — instead of two inner buckets, it uses a Liner Rim System on the trash side. That rim grips the bag directly, which frees up 25% more space inside compared to a can that has a plastic bucket taking up interior volume. The recycling side still gets a handled inner bucket that lifts straight out so you can carry it to the curb without wrestling the bag.
The pedal is rated for 150,000 steps — simplehuman engineers claim that covers over 20 steps a day for two decades. Buyers report the Lid Shox motion control delivers a slow, silent close every time, and the recessed lid stops pets from pawing it open. One reviewer noted the interior bag storage dispenses liners one by one from inside the can, so you never hunt for a fresh bag again. At 14.2 inches deep and 22 inches wide, it takes up more counter-adjacent width than narrower models, but you get the most refined daily experience in the category.
The catch: The custom-fit Code H liners cost more than generic bags, and there is no inner bucket on the trash side to lift out for a full wash — you wipe the interior instead.
Reach for this if: you want the most thoughtfully engineered dual bin that keeps trash and recycling separated without a second can, and you do not mind paying for simplehuman’s custom liner system.
Look elsewhere if: you want to use any cheap bag you find at the store and prefer a full inner bucket you can lift out for a hose-down.
2. SONGMICS Trash Can, 2 x 8 Gallon (2 x 30 L)
The double bin that pairs a 180,000-step pedal with a soft-close lid that stays open at 90 degrees.
SONGMICS built this around two 8-gallon inner buckets that lift out using side handles — so emptying and cleaning is straightforward. The brushed stainless steel body resists fingerprints and scratches, and the lids are also stainless steel, which gives the whole unit a more premium feel than cans with plastic lids. The pedal is tested for over 180,000 steps, beating the simplehuman’s 150,000 rating by a solid margin.
Each lid can remain open at a 90-degree angle while you cook or clean, then the soft-close mechanism lowers it silently. Buyers mention the compartments are spacious for the footprint and that the included 15 liner bags mean you can start using it immediately. At 20.4 pounds it is lighter than the simplehuman, but the all-metal construction contributes to that sturdiness. One buyer mentioned the inner bucket handles occasionally pop off, though most call it a great value for a well-built dual can.
The honest read: You get two proper stainless steel lids, a high-step-count pedal, and lift-out buckets at a price that undercuts many competitors.
For the buyer who wants: a straightforward, sturdy dual compartment can with stainless lids and a long-lasting pedal, no proprietary bags needed.
One real downside: the inner bucket handles can detach, and some buyers find the cans themselves small for a 16-gallon total rating.
3. Lovewind Dual Trash and Recycling Bins, 19+8 Gallon (72+30L)
The oversized bin for households that generate pizza boxes and bulk waste daily.
Lovewind takes the dual compartment idea and scales it up to a total 27 gallons — a 19-gallon main side and an 8-gallon recycling side. That main compartment is big enough for standard 20-gallon bags, which means you stop crushing boxes or changing bags twice a day. The unit measures 28.2 inches long, so it demands more floor space than other picks, but for a family of four or five that cooks at home, the extra capacity is a real time saver.
The reinforced steel pedal is rated for up to 200,000 presses, the highest step count in this lineup alongside the Arlopu. The hydraulic soft-close hinges prevent the lid from slamming, and the lid locks at a 90-degree stay-open position for hands-free peeling and scraping. Owners mention the unit is sturdy, silent, and effectively traps smells inside. The dual compartments use removable inner buckets made of PP plastic, and two magnetic sorting stickers come included to label each side.
Why this stands out
- Largest total capacity on the list at 27 gallons
- 200,000-step pedal outlasts most households
- Stainless steel body with smudge-proof finish
The trade-off
- 28.2-inch length takes up more cabinet frontage
- Heavier at 24.6 pounds when moving for cleaning
This is your pick if: you run through a standard 13-gallon can in a day and need the main side to handle bulky waste without constant bag changes.
skip it if: your kitchen has tight clearance beside the counter or under an overhang — measure that 28.2-inch width first.
4. GarveeHome 2 x 8 gal Stainless Steel Double Trash Can
The fingerprint-resistant metal can that fits below a standard 36-inch island countertop.
GarveeHome designed this to sit flush under a kitchen island — the lid opens to 80 degrees without hitting the counter edge and locks at 95 degrees when you need hands-free access. The body uses 410-grade ferritic stainless steel, which resists rust and scratches, and the finish is fingerprint-resistant. Each inner bucket holds the equivalent of 24 standard 16.9 oz water bottles or 48 12 oz cans, giving a solid 8-gallon capacity per side.
The pedal is built for over 150,000 steps, and the one-piece ABS hinge is tested past 300,000 open/close cycles — that is more hinge cycles than any other can here. Customers note the unit is well-made and looks modern, though some note that standard 8-gallon bags do not fit the inner buckets well and that 13-gallon bags are oversized. One reviewer found that Simplehuman size G bags fit perfectly as a replacement. The liner rim conceals bag edges for a clean silhouette, and anti-slip rubber feet keep it planted on tile or hardwood.
The takeaway: A well-engineered compact dual can with a standout hinge rating, but expect to experiment with bag sizes to find your fit.
Grab this if: you need a dual can that tucks under an island without hitting the counter and you want a dent-resistant, fingerprint-proof finish.
One irritation to know: standard bags do not fit well — you will likely need Simplehuman size G bags or a separate bag cinch.
5. Arlopu 16Gal Dual Trash Can w/ 2 Built-in Box for Odor Control
The stainless steel can with hidden compartments in the lids for odor-fighting refills.
Arlopu adds a twist that no other can here has — each lid has a built-in box designed to hold a cleaning material or odor absorber to help improve air quality around the trash can. The lids themselves use a slow-close mechanism that drops silently once your foot leaves the pedal. The pedal is made of stainless steel and tested for over 200,000 uses, matching the Lovewind for the highest step count on the list.
The outer body is 410 stainless steel with a fingerprint-resistant, stain-resistant surface. Two removable ABS inner buckets each hold 8 gallons, and the buckets have pocket holes to hold your plastic bags in place. Reviewers point out the foot pedal opens the lid smoothly with no harsh force, and the rubber base prevents the unit from sliding on hard floors. At 23 pounds it is on the heavier side, but that weight comes from the steel construction and the sealing base that is both pet-proof and waterproof.
The one-two punch: A 200,000-plus step pedal plus built-in odor control make this a smart pick for a kitchen that sees fish, coffee grounds, or other strong-smelling waste.
Choose this if: odor containment is your top priority and you want a pedal rated for decades of use.
Keep in mind: the pedals are on the smaller side, and some shoppers say there is no designated bag slit on the inner bins.
6. Simpli-Magic 60 Liter / 16 Gallon Dual Compartment Step Trash Can
The white steel bin with color-coded liners and a filter pocket for odor control.
Simpli-Magic ships this with color-coded liners — black for the 30-liter trash side and green for the 30-liter recycling side — so everyone in the household knows which compartment gets what. The body is a combination of plastic and stainless steel, which keeps the weight down to 15 pounds, lighter than most other 16-gallon dual cans. The brushed finish hides fingerprints and smudges well.
A built-in filter holder sits inside the lid, ready for an odor control refill. The slow-close lid operates quietly, and a lid lock keeps the top open at an extended angle for longer tasks. Buyers report the compartments are nicely large for the size, the lids seal well to contain smells, and standard 13-gallon bags work without sliding off. Some mention it takes a small wiggle to settle the liner into place, but overall it is an easy-to-clean can that looks good against the wall.
Who it works for: If you want color-coded sorting at a glance and a lighter can that still offers a filter pocket and slow-close lid — without paying for a premium brand name.
A solid mid-range option if: you want a simple, functional dual can with filter support that works with standard bags.
Not the pick if: you want an all-metal build or a pedal with a published step-test rating.
7. Step N’ Sort 2 x 5.5 Gallon, Dual Trash and Recycling Bin
The lightweight plastic dual bin that teaches kids which side is which.
Step N’ Sort strips the concept down to its essentials: two 20-liter (5.5-gallon) plastic compartments in a single frame that weighs only 6 pounds. At 6 pounds versus the SONGMICS at 20.4 pounds, you can pick it up and move it between rooms without any effort. The foot pedal opens both lids simultaneously or each individually, which is a nice touch for a budget-priced unit.
The removable inner bins have handles for easy emptying and cleaning, and a built-in liner pocket holds the bag in place. Owners mention the soft-close lids are quiet and that the compact size fits neatly in small kitchens, dorm rooms, or laundry areas — one owner reported it helps kids learn where to put recycling. At 17 inches long by 13 inches wide by 21 inches tall, it fits easily in tight spaces.
Where it shines
- Lightest dual can on the list at just 6 pounds
- Each compartment opens independently via the pedal
- Compact footprint fits small kitchens, dorms, and laundry rooms
The limitation
- 5.5 gallons per side means frequent bag changes for busy households
- All-plastic build lacks the premium feel of stainless steel models
Best for: a small apartment, a kid’s room, or a secondary sorting station where weight and size matter more than total capacity.
Not ideal for: a large family kitchen that produces more than one bag of waste per day.
Understanding the Specs
Pedal Step Count
This number tells you how many times the pedal mechanism is tested to work before failure. A higher rating (150,000 to 200,000 steps) means the internal spring and hinge will not loosen or snap after a few years. For a family kitchen, aim for at least 150,000 steps — that covers about 20 presses a day for 20 years.
Soft-Close Mechanism
Soft-close lids use a hydraulic damper or a spring with friction control to slow the lid’s descent. Without it, the lid slams every time your foot leaves the pedal. This matters most in open-concept homes or if you take out trash late at night and do not want to wake anyone.
Liner Rim vs Inner Bucket
A liner rim holds the bag directly against the can’s interior wall, giving you more usable space because there is no plastic bucket taking up volume. An inner bucket lifts out for easy washing and lets you carry the waste to the outdoor bin without wrestling the bag. Which one you prefer depends on whether you value extra capacity or easier cleaning.
FAQ
Will a dual compartment trash can fit under a standard kitchen counter?
Can I use regular trash bags in a dual compartment can with inner buckets?
How do I clean a dual compartment trash can with removable buckets?
Do dual compartment trash cans contain odors well?
Which dual compartment can is best for a family of four or more?
Are dual compartment trash cans pet-proof?
How long should the pedal on a dual compartment trash can last?
What is the difference between a liner rim and a removable inner bucket?
Can I open one compartment at a time or do both lids open together?
Which dual compartment trash can is the easiest to move between rooms?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
You want a dual compartment trash can that makes sorting trash and recycling easy without taking up extra floor space. The SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon is the best value for most people because its foot pedal lasts 180,000 steps (so you won’t break it after a year), both lids are stainless steel, the inner buckets lift out for cleaning, and it even comes with liner bags — all at a price that balances solid build and affordability. If you want the smoothest daily sorting experience, the simplehuman Step Recycler has a liner rim system that holds bags tight and gives you more usable space inside. And for big households that need maximum capacity, the Lovewind 19+8 Gallon offers a 200,000-step pedal and handles bulk waste so you change bags less often.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gardening Beyond earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.