6 Best Dummies for 2 Year Olds | Soft Latex vs Strong Silicone

Check Price on Amazon

The soft latex pacifier that has kept babies happy for over forty years.

BIBS built its reputation on mimicking the shape and feel of a mother’s breast, and the Fusion 2-Pack carries that tradition into the toddler years. The teat is made from natural rubber latex, which gives it a soft, pliable texture that babies who started on these early tend to refuse to give up. At size 3 (18-36 months), it fits a two-year-old comfortably without being too large in the shield.

Buyers report these are durable and hold up well being washed over and over — but there is a trade-off. Natural rubber expands as baby sucks, and over time the teat can pop. BIBS itself recommends replacing every 4-6 weeks. That is faster turnover than silicone, but families who have already used BIBS since birth say their child simply will not take anything else.

Compared to the 4-count BIBS Colour Soother, this 2-pack costs less upfront, making it a smarter entry point for parents new to the brand. If your toddler is an aggressive chewer who destroyed other brands in days, the rubber here feels soft but is not as bite-resistant as a silicone alternative like the NUK below.

Check Price on Amazon

The featherlight silicone design that stays put and survives chewing.

Tommee Tippee calls this its lightest pacifier ever, and the weight difference is noticeable the moment you pick it up. The one-piece construction, made entirely from BPA-free silicone, means no separate parts to trap moisture or come loose — simply toss it in the dishwasher to clean. A symmetrical nipple design ensures the pacifier goes into baby’s mouth the right way up every time, so no middle-of-the-night fumbling to flip it.

One reviewer noted that the size 18-36 months fits a 7-year-old, which tells you this pacifier skews generously large — perfect for a two-year-old with a bigger mouth, but potentially too bulky for an 18-month border case. The curved shield is shaped to sit comfortably under the nose and above the chin, and the air holes let skin breathe, reducing the chance of irritation or rash around the mouth.

Where the BIBS Fusion pack gives you softness, this Tommee Tippee pack delivers toughness — the silicone withstands determined chewing and comes in a 4-count, making it the smarter buy for parents who want fewer replacements and more spares in the diaper bag.

Check Price on Amazon

The orthodontic shape that outlasted a pricier rival by months.

If you are concerned about how a pacifier might affect your toddler’s developing teeth and jaw, the NUK Orthodontic 4-Pack addresses that directly. The nipple is asymmetrical with a scooped bottom—flatter to allow more room for natural sucking motion, and slimmer to reduce pressure on teeth. The heart-shaped shield sits perfectly under the nose for easy breathing, and the silicone nipple is BPA-free and top-rack dishwasher safe.

Owners mention a specific durability edge here: one buyer mentioned the NUK survived 2 months of toddler chewing and drooling, while a pricier brand failed in just 2 weeks. That is a significant difference for a child who still relies on a pacifier to self-soothe or break a finger-sucking habit. The 4-pack at a mid-range price point makes this one of the better value propositions on the list, especially compared to the smaller-count premium picks.

Compared to the orthodontic Simply Rubber below, the NUK uses silicone rather than natural rubber, so it will not degrade as fast under daily chewing. But that also means it lacks the soft, pliable feel of latex — babies who are attached to a soft teat may reject the firmer silicone.

Check Price on Amazon

Italian artisans craft each one by hand over six weeks — and it shows.

Simply Rubber takes a slower approach: each pacifier goes through a curing process that takes six weeks from start to finish, assembled entirely by hand in Italy. The result is a one-piece natural rubber design that has no seams or separate parts, making it both easier to clean and safer in line with the American Academy of Pediatrics recommendation for one-piece pacifiers. The orthodontic nipple is flattened on the bottom and rounded on top, designed to prevent dental misalignment as teeth emerge.

Customers note mixed experiences on size. One parent noted they bought the largest size and it seemed like a six-month size compared to other brands — so if your toddler has a larger mouth, this may feel small. Another said their toddler had not bitten through it after four days, which is promising given the softness of natural rubber. The two vent holes in the shield allow air flow and may reduce face marks.

Unlike the NUK, which uses silicone for durability, this is a pure natural rubber product — soft and breast-like, but vulnerable to chewing damage. It is a premium pick for parents who prioritize material purity and craftsmanship over toughness.

Check Price on Amazon

A plant-based, biodegradable pacifier that is as soft as it is eco-friendly.

HEVEA stands apart because every part of the pacifier is made from 100% natural rubber — even the packaging is FSC-certified with a plant-based window. That means no plastic, no BPA, no PVC, no phthalates, and the entire pacifier is biodegradable. The orthodontic teat has a flattened bottom and round top to help prevent tooth misalignment, and there is a tiny ventilation hole in the teat that makes the rubber exceptionally soft and malleable for baby.

Buyers love the material — one noted that their baby makes a cute little sucky sound, and another said it has been their favorite natural pacifier for over four years. However, a significant number of reviewers flag the size as much smaller than anticipated. One parent wrote that they definitely are not for an 18-month-old or older and would be better sized for a 6-month-old. For a two-year-old with a full mouth, this is a genuine concern, especially when compared against the generously sized Tommee Tippee or BIBS Colour Soother.

The one-piece design is hygienic and easy to clean — no hidden crevices — and the big flexible loop lets you hook it on your finger or a clip. But on size alone, this may work best for a petite toddler or a child transitioning down from a bigger dummy.

Check Price on Amazon

The premium 4-pack with glow-in-the-dark shields and Danish craftsmanship.

If you already know your toddler loves BIBS, the Colour Soother 4-Pack is the upgrade that covers every room of the house. It uses the same natural rubber latex and round nipple design as the Fusion 2-Pack but doubles the count, making it the highest-count BIBS option on this list. Beyond the quantity, the Blush Glow Mix shields actually glow in the dark — a small but real convenience for middle-of-the-night retrievals without turning on a light.

Buyers consistently rate these as the best pacifiers for fit, noting they stay in the mouth even during yawning or crying, and the shield does not leave red marks on the face. The shape is designed to prevent full mouth insertion during sleep, and the natural rubber is non-toxic with consistent quality across units. One parent noted these are similar to the Itzy Ritzy brand at the same price point and recommended trying a single pacifier first before committing to the full 4-pack.

The trade-off — as with all natural rubber latex — is durability. BIBS Colour Soother holds 4 pacifiers versus BIBS Fusion’s 2. But four pacifiers that need monthly replacement add up faster than a single 4-pack of silicone. If your toddler chews hard, the NUK or Tommee Tippee will outlast these.