Our readers keep the lights on and the coffee maker working hard! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Wedding favors are a tricky thing — you want guests to remember your day, but most trinkets end up in a drawer or left on the table. Edible wedding favors solve that problem because people actually eat them. The challenge is picking something that tastes good, fits your theme, and gives you enough for every guest without blowing your budget. This guide cuts through the options to find the real winners.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Whether you are planning a sit-down dinner or a casual reception, the right treat keeps the celebration going. Read on for the six best edible wedding favors that guests will actually reach for.
Quick Picks
- Best Day Ever Spot Mint to Be Wedding Favors — Best Overall
- A Great Surprise Thank You Mints — Approx. 300 Pieces — Best Value
- Party Sweets By Hospitality Mints Wedding Buttermints — Crowd Favorite
- M&M’S World Miss to Mrs. Themed Packs (30 Count) — Premium Touch
- M&M’S World Milk Chocolate Wedding Candy Favors (20 Pack) — Trusted Classic
- Wint O Green Hard Candy 2lb Pack of Mints — Budget Champion
How To Choose The Best Edible Wedding Favors
You want a favor your guests will actually eat, not leave behind. The best edible wedding favor for you depends on your guest count, the flavor that fits your wedding style, and if you want a custom look without the custom price. Here is what to think through before you add anything to your cart.
Count the pieces, not just the pounds
A 2-pound bag sounds like a lot until you realize each guest might grab several mints from the dish. Start by estimating 5 to 10 pieces per person depending on how long the event runs. If your wedding has 100 guests, a 3-pound bag that holds around 300 pieces gives you about three mints per person. For larger weddings, multiple bags or bigger pack sizes become necessary.
Individually wrapped vs. bulk unwrapped
Individually wrapped mints and candies keep each piece fresh and hygienic — guests can grab one without touching the rest. This matters at a wedding reception where hands pass through the candy dish all evening. Bulk unwrapped candies look beautiful in a glass jar but can get sticky if the room is warm, and they do not hold up as well in favor bags.
Flavor and season go hand in hand
Wintergreen and spearmint mints are a classic year-round choice, but for an outdoor summer wedding, something lighter like a buttermint (soft and creamy with real peppermint oil) feels more appropriate. Chocolate candies are always popular, but they need cooler temperatures to travel and stay intact — one reviewer noted having their M&M’s delivered to a Whole Foods so they wouldn’t melt.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Best For | Total Pieces | Weight | Flavor | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Day Ever Spot Mint to Be Favor | Customizable wedding favors | 100 Count | — | Life Savers | Amazon |
| M&M’S World Miss to Mrs. Candies | Bridal shower & bachelorette parties | 30 Count | 1.5 Pounds | Milk Chocolate | Amazon |
| M&M’S World Wedding Candy Favors | Classic chocolate fans | 20 Count | 15.0 Ounce | Milk Chocolate | Amazon |
| Party Sweets Wedding Buttermints | Traditional soft mints | 330 total | 42.0 Ounce | Buttermint | Amazon |
| Wint O Green Hard Candy Mints | Budget-friendly bulk wintergreen | — | 2.03 Pounds | Wintergreen | Amazon |
| A Great Surprise Thank You Mints | Largest piece count per dollar | Approx. 300 | 3 Pounds | Spearmint | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Best Day Ever Spot Mint to Be Wedding Favors
A personalized sweet that makes every guest feel like the favor was made just for them.
This is the standout choice for couples who want a favor that looks custom without spending days assembling it. Each clear pack contains individually wrapped Life Savers with your own text printed on the label — the packaging says “FREE Personalization!” and arrives fully assembled, ready to hand out. At 100 pieces per order, this works best for small to mid-size weddings where you want each guest to walk away with a favor that plainly says your names and date.
Because it uses Life Savers rather than a soft mint, the candy holds up well in any climate and won’t melt in a gift bag left in a car. Buyers report “these little mints are so cute and very tasty” — one reviewer used them for her daughter’s wedding and said guests absolutely loved them. The trade-off is the per-piece count: at 100 pieces, a large 200-guest wedding would need two sets, which pushes the total cost higher than bulk bag options.
Why it stands out
- Printed with your custom text — no assembly needed
- Sturdy Life Savers candy resists heat and travel
- Favor packs come ready-to-give straight from the box
What to weigh
- 100 pieces per order may require multiple sets for larger weddings
- Higher cost per piece compared to bulk mints
The personalized pick: Ideal for a mid-size wedding where you want a favor that feels thoughtfully made for each guest without manual labor.
Reality check: For a guest list over 120, you will likely need to order at least two batches, which pushes the budget beyond most bulk mint options.
2. A Great Surprise Thank You Mints — Approx. 300 Pieces
Three pounds of elegant mints that disappear from the dish before the first dance ends.
If your priority is volume — a lot of mints that look classy and cost very little per piece — this is the bag to grab. At 3 pounds and approximately 300 pieces, this gives you the largest piece count in the entire roundup. It weighs 3 pounds versus the Wint O Green bag at 2.03 pounds, so you get noticeably more candy for your budget. Each mint is individually wrapped in a sophisticated white wrapper with black “Thank You” lettering, making it feel right at home on a wedding dessert table or in favor bags.
One buyer mentioned “bigger and way more than I expected no complaints” — these mints are larger than typical butter mints and have a texture closer to Brach’s starlight mints. The spearmint flavor is refreshing without being overpowering, and the wrappers double as a built-in thank-you note so you don’t need separate tags. The catch is that the “Thank You” text is pre-printed, not customizable, so it works best as a general favor rather than a personalized couple-specific keepsake.
Volume advantage
- Approx. 300 pieces from a 3-pound bag — plenty for 100+ guests
- Sophisticated white wrapper with “Thank You” printed text
- Owners mention the taste is great and quality is solid
What to consider
- Pre-printed “Thank You” cannot be personalized with names or dates
- Not a buttermint — bigger, harder texture like a starlight mint
The bulk champ: Buy this if you need a huge quantity of classy mints and do not need custom printing — it is the most efficient way to cover 100 guests.
skip it if: You want each favor to carry your names and wedding date; the pre-printed wrapper has no room for customization.
3. Party Sweets By Hospitality Mints Wedding Buttermints
Soft, buttery, and genuinely hard to keep the dish full — the classic wedding mint done right.
These are the iconic buttermints that have been showing up at wedding receptions for decades, and for good reason. You get six 7-ounce bags, each holding about 55 mints for a total of 330 pieces. That puts it in the same ballpark as the A Great Surprise bag for quantity, but the experience is completely different: these are soft, melt-in-your-mouth buttermints made with triple-distilled peppermint oil, real butter, and pure cane sugar. They are also gluten free, fat free, Kosher, and contain no trans fat, which helps if any guests have dietary restrictions.
Customers note “bought for my daughter’s wedding reception and we couldn’t keep the dishes full!” — the mints went fast at both the entrance and dessert table. The individually wrapped pieces do have sweet sayings printed on each wrapper, giving them extra personality. A few reviewers noted the wrappers have inconsistent ink darkness, and the price is higher per piece compared to plain bulk mints. Unlike the M&M’s options below, these do not need temperature control, so they travel easily.
What makes it special
- Soft buttermint with real butter and peppermint oil — a premium feel
- 330 total pieces across six 7-ounce bags
- Gluten free, fat free, Kosher, no trans fat
Possible downsides
- Higher cost per piece compared to standard hard mints
- Wrapper ink darkness can vary between pieces
The traditionalist’s choice: Go for these if you want the classic wedding flavor that guests actually gobble up — they vanish fast for a reason.
A small trade-off: The per-piece cost is higher than standard wintergreen or spearmint mints, so budget-conscious weddings may prefer a larger bulk bag.
4. M&M’S World Miss to Mrs. Themed Packs (30 Count)
Custom-printed chocolates that bring a playful, colorful energy to your bridal shower or bachelorette party.
This set of 30 packs features M&M’s in pink, cream, and white, each printed with “Bride to Be” and “She Said Yes.” At 30 count, this is a smaller quantity than the bulk mints above, so it is best suited for an intimate event like a bridal shower or the rehearsal dinner rather than a full wedding reception of 150 guests. Each pack holds 0.75 ounces of chocolate — the same serving size as the 20-pack option below.
One reviewer who used these in wedding favor boxes said they “survived shipping to South Africa without melting/breaking” and that the print maintained “solid color, no shine-through.” Other guests noted they are a crowd pleaser that kids love. The main difference from the next M&M’s option is the phrase printed on each piece — this one leans toward the engagement/bridal shower theme, while the 20-pack below uses wedding-themed graphics. Both require cool storage: a reviewer specifically had theirs delivered to Whole Foods to avoid melting in transit, so plan for warm-weather handling.
Why this works
- Chocolate candies printed with “Bride to Be” and “She Said Yes” — perfect for the pre-wedding phase
- Tested by buyers to survive international shipping without damage
- Three color mix (pink, cream, white) fits bridal shower aesthetics
Considerations
- Only 30 packs — not enough for a full wedding reception
- Heat-sensitive; needs cool delivery and storage to avoid melting
Best for smaller events: Grab these for the bridal shower or bachelorette gathering where a smaller, themed treat makes sense.
Not for the big day: With only 30 packs, a 100+ guest wedding would need multiple orders, and heat handling requires planning.
5. M&M’S World Milk Chocolate Wedding Candy Favors (20 Pack)
A 20-pack of printed M&M’s that guests of all ages reach for before the speeches even start.
This pack contains 20 individual 0.75-ounce pouches of M&M’s in white, cream, and black with wedding-themed graphics printed directly on each chocolate. It is a smaller quantity than the Miss to Mrs. set above (20 packs vs 30 packs), but the color palette is broader — the addition of black candies gives it a more formal, tuxedo-and-gown look that fits directly on a wedding dessert table. One owner reported “good for wedding favor boxes; survived shipping to South Africa without melting/breaking” which speaks to sturdy packaging when handled correctly.
At 15.0 ounces total, this is the smallest total weight in the comparison — 15.0 ounces versus the A Great Surprise bag at 3 pounds. That means it works best as a supplement to your main favor or for a small, intimate ceremony. The 20-pack and the 30-pack Miss to Mrs. option both offer fewer packs than the 100-count Best Day Ever set. Warm weather is your main enemy here: the candies have edible prints that degrade if left in direct sunlight or high temperatures, so coordinate delivery timing carefully.
What you get
- Wedding-themed graphics printed on each candy — white, cream, black colors
- Tested by reviewers to survive international shipping without melting or breaking
- Familiar M&M’s taste that kids and adults both love
Watch for
- Only 20 packs — not enough volume for a large wedding
- Chocolate can melt in warm conditions; requires cool storage
The small-ceremony favor: Excellent for a courthouse wedding or elopement after-party where each guest gets a single high-quality treat.
Not for 100+ guest lists: The pack count is low, and you would need multiple sets that combined cost more than a single bulk mint bag.
6. Wint O Green Hard Candy 2lb Pack of Mints
An honest, no-frills wintergreen mint that gives you the most candy for your dollar.
This 2-pound bulk bag of individually wrapped Wint O Green hard candies is the most budget-friendly entry in the lineup. At 2.03 pounds, it is lighter than the A Great Surprise bag at 3 pounds but still delivers a solid volume of individually wrapped pieces. The wintergreen flavor is familiar and refreshing — the kind of mint you remember from church basements and grandmother’s candy dish. One customer observed “I buy these just about every month for my church,” which speaks to the reliable quality and steady demand.
The bag weighs 2.03 pounds versus 3 pounds for the A Great Surprise bag, so you get noticeably fewer pieces. Each mint is wrapped for freshness and travels well, making them a good pick for wedding favor bags that sit on tables for hours. The wrappers are plain and do not have any wedding-themed text, so you will need to add your own tags or labels if you want personalization. If your wedding is a casual, laid-back affair where the candy speaks for itself, this is the most cost-efficient way to cover every seat.
What works
- Lowest cost per bag among all picks — maximum coverage for a tight budget
- Individually wrapped for freshness and easy grab-and-go
- Reviewers praise the classic wintergreen flavor and consistency
Trade-offs
- No wedding-specific wrapper design — you will need to add tags for personalization
- 2.03 pounds is lighter than the 3-pound A Great Surprise bag
The budget-first pick: If your priority is keeping the per-guest cost low while still giving everyone a wrapped mint, this bag delivers the best value.
Not for themed events: The plain wrapper does not scream “wedding” — you will need to dress it up with stickers or ribbon if a polished look matters to you.
Understanding the Specs
Total weight vs. total pieces
The weight of the bag tells you how heavy the shipment is, but it does not always tell you how many individual mints you get. For example, the A Great Surprise bag is 3 pounds and roughly 300 pieces, while the Party Sweets Buttermints are 42 ounces across six bags and total 330 pieces. Pieces can vary in size — buttermints are smaller than hard starlight-style mints — so always look at the piece count or estimated servings first, then use the weight to compare value between similar candy types.
Individually wrapped vs. bulk unwrapped
Individually wrapped candies keep each piece fresh and allow guests to grab one without touching the others. This is important at a wedding where bowls sit out for hours and multiple hands reach in. All six picks in this guide are individually wrapped, which is a big advantage for hygiene and convenience. Bulk unwrapped candies look pretty in a jar but can get sticky in warm rooms and do not transfer easily into favor bags.
FAQ
How many mints should I budget per wedding guest?
Will chocolate favors melt during summer weddings or shipping?
Can I get my names or wedding date printed on the wrappers?
Are these mints gluten-free or suitable for dietary restrictions?
How do I choose between spearmint, wintergreen, and buttermint?
Should I buy one large bag or several smaller bags?
Can I use these favors for a bridal shower or bachelorette party?
How long do these candies stay fresh if I buy them early?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most couples, the edible wedding favors winner is the Best Day Ever Spot Mint to Be Wedding Favors because it combines personalized packaging with a sturdy, heat-friendly candy that arrives fully assembled. If you want maximum quantity for a large guest list, grab the A Great Surprise Thank You Mints — at 3 pounds and roughly 300 pieces, it is the best way to cover 100+ guests efficiently. And for the classic buttermint experience that guests cannot resist, the Party Sweets Wedding Buttermints have a decades-long track record of emptying dishes before the reception ends.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement, and we did not hands-on test every unit. Instead, we match each pick to a real buyer and use-case by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications against the patterns in verified customer reviews — so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing copy.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gardening Beyond earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.