Our readers keep the lights on and the coffee maker working hard! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
An electric reel mower strips away the noise, fumes, and maintenance of a gas engine while delivering the cleanest scissor-cut your turf can get. But not all models are created equal — some rely on pure human push power, while others pair a brushless motor with a spinning reel for effortless trimming. The trade-offs in cutting width, blade count, battery runtime, and self-propel capability can make or break your weekly mow.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. I analyze market data, compare spec sheets, study owner reports, and evaluate seasonal durability to separate the workhorses from the duds in this narrow category.
Whether you want a lightweight manual reel mower for a tidy city lawn or a self-propelled cordless machine that handles a half-acre lot, I’ll help you pinpoint the model that fits your grass type, terrain, and cutting preferences. This guide compares nine top contenders to help you find the best electric reel mower for your yard.
How To Choose The Best Electric Reel Mower
Selecting the right electric reel mower means balancing your lawn size, grass type, and willingness to push against a spinning reel. Here are the critical specs to evaluate before you buy.
Blade Count: 5-Blade vs 7-Blade Reels
A 5-blade reel is the standard option for small, well-maintained lawns with thin grass. A 7-blade reel cuts finer and handles thicker Bermuda or Zoysia without leaving uncut strips. More blades also mean more drag, so 7-blade manual models require slightly more push effort than their 5-blade counterparts.
Cutting Width and Mowing Speed
An 18-inch deck covers about 1.5 square feet per linear foot of travel, while a 20-inch or 21-inch deck pushes that to roughly 1.75 square feet. For a 2,500-square-foot lawn, an 18-inch mower requires around 1,660 linear feet of walking, whereas a 21-inch mower cuts that to about 1,430 feet — a meaningful time savings on larger lots.
Manual vs Cordless Motorized
Manual reel mowers rely entirely on your forward motion to spin the reel — lighter and quieter but require a consistent walking pace. Cordless motorized models use a brushless motor to spin the reel independently, so the blades keep rotating even when you stop or slow down, delivering a more consistent cut on irregular terrain. Self-propel models add a drive motor for the wheels, eliminating the push effort entirely.
Cutting Height Range and Adjustment
Most reel mowers adjust between 1 and 3 inches. A wider range (1.25 to 4 inches) offers more flexibility for cool-season grasses or seasonal changes. Single-lever height adjustments are faster and more convenient than individual wheel adjustments.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EGO POWER+ LM2114SP | Premium | Best overall performance | 6.0 ft-lbs cutting torque | Amazon |
| Greenworks 80V 21″ | Premium | Large lawns, turbo mode | 80V 4.0Ah, 21″ steel deck | Amazon |
| Wild Badger Power 40V 21″ | Premium | Medium-to-large lawns | 2× 4.0Ah batteries included | Amazon |
| SKIL PWR CORE 40 SM4910C-11 | Mid-Range | Self-propel on slopes | Variable speed self-propel | Amazon |
| American Lawn Mower 51319 | Mid-Range | Corded electric reliability | 13-Amp motor, 19″ deck | Amazon |
| RB 9″ Mini Cordless | Mid-Range | Tiny spaces, bumpy ground | 9″ deck, 11.5 lbs weight | Amazon |
| Scotts 2000-20S | Budget | Classic manual value | 20″ 5-blade manual reel | Amazon |
| Scotts 716-18S | Budget | Finer cut at low cost | 18″ 7-blade manual reel | Amazon |
| American Lawn Mower 1804-18 | Budget | Entry-level manual mowing | 18″ 5-blade, included catcher | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. EGO POWER+ Electric Mower LM2114SP
The EGO LM2114SP delivers 6.0 ft-lbs of cutting torque — enough to out-cut many gas-powered walk-behinds. Its 56V ARC Lithium battery provides up to 50 minutes of runtime on a single charge, and the 21-inch steel deck covers ground efficiently. The dual-toggle self-propel system lets you engage drive with either hand, a thoughtful ergonomic touch for varied terrain.
Pros consistently praise its clean cut on thick St. Augustine and Bermuda, and the push-button start eliminates the pull-cord struggle entirely. The 7-position height adjustment ranges from 1.25 to 4 inches, covering both tight warm-season cuts and taller cool-season settings. The LED headlights extend usable mowing time into early evening.
The flip side: at 84 pounds, it’s one of the heavier cordless models, and the self-propel can feel too fast for very small lawns. Some owners recommend buying a secondary battery for lots over a quarter acre. Overall, the torque, build quality, and EGO platform compatibility make it the premium benchmark.
What works
- Exceptional cutting torque exceeds most gas mowers
- Dual-toggle self-propel for left/right engagement
- 7-position height range from 1.25 to 4 inches
What doesn’t
- Heavy at 84 pounds — not ideal for steep slopes
- Single battery may not cover larger lawns
- Self-propel speed can feel aggressive in tight spaces
2. Greenworks 80V 21″ Self-Propelled Cordless Mower
Greenworks packs an 80V 4.0Ah battery into this 21-inch rear-wheel drive self-propelled mower, delivering enough torque for half-acre lots. The brushless motor runs significantly quieter than gas, and the 4-in-1 system (mulch, bag, side discharge, turbo leaf pickup) gives you flexible clipping management. The turbo mode kicks in extra power for thick patches without bogging down.
Users highlight the near-silent operation — neighbors rarely hear it running. The rear-wheel drive provides solid traction on slopes, and the variable speed control lets you match the walk pace. Assembly is minimal, and the folding handle saves garage space. The single-lever height adjustment (7 positions) is fast to use mid-mow.
Downsides: the self-propel wheels can lock when turning if you don’t disengage early, and the mulch quality is only adequate — not as fine as gas rotary mulchers. The bag is on the smaller side, requiring frequent emptying on larger lawns. Battery life runs about 30 minutes under turbo load, so a spare battery is recommended for heavier use.
What works
- 80V battery handles half-acre yards
- Turbo mode clears thick grass without stalling
- Near-silent operation for early/late mowing
What doesn’t
- Self-propel wheels lock during sharp turns
- Mulch quality is adequate, not exceptional
- Grass bag fills quickly on larger lawns
3. Wild Badger Power 40V 21″ Cordless Mower
The Wild Badger Power mower comes with two 4.0Ah 40V batteries and a fast charger, covering up to 6,534 square feet per charge cycle. The 21-inch deck provides 17% more coverage per pass than an 18-inch mower, and the 4-in-1 grass handling (bagging, mulching, side discharge, rear discharge) gives complete flexibility. The variable-speed self-propel system adjusts to your natural walking stride.
Owners report easy assembly, a lightweight feel (53 pounds), and a clean, even cut. The single-lever height adjustment (7 positions from 1.18 to 3.55 inches) is back-friendly and quick. The folding handle and compact upright storage are space-saving bonuses for garage organization.
Weaknesses: battery life per pack is around 30-45 minutes under normal use, so the second battery is essential for larger yards. A few users experienced battery failure after one season, citing lack of detailed storage instructions. Replacement 40V batteries are not as widely available as 56V or 80V platforms. The 3-year warranty and US-based support help mitigate reliability concerns.
What works
- Includes two batteries for extended runtime
- 21-inch deck reduces mowing time
- Lightweight at 53 pounds with self-propel
What doesn’t
- Battery life per pack is moderate
- Replacement 40V batteries are niche
- Some reliability concerns after one season
4. SKIL PWR CORE 40 SM4910C-11
SKIL’s PWR CORE 40 offers a variable-speed self-propel system paired with a digital brushless motor for efficient power delivery. The 20-inch deck fits through standard gates, and the included 6.0Ah battery delivers up to 50 minutes of runtime. Push-button start and a foldable telescoping handle make this a convenient mid-range option for medium lawns.
Users appreciate the lightweight feel — noticeably easier to maneuver than gas mowers — and the ability to adjust self-propel speed to match terrain. The 7-position single-lever height adjustment (1.5 to 4 inches) is simple to operate mid-mow. The 3-in-1 system (bagging, mulching, rear discharge) covers basic clipping needs.
On the downside, the self-propel dead-man switch can snag pockets, and the lowest height setting clogs easily on grass taller than 4 inches. Some owners note that battery voltage reads 42V max (37V rated), which is lower than other 40V platforms. For flat to moderate slopes under half an acre, this SKIL delivers reliable self-propel performance at a mid-range price.
What works
- Variable-speed self-propel adapts to terrain
- Lightweight design, easy to maneuver
- Push-button start — no pull cord
What doesn’t
- Self-propel dead-man switch snags clothing
- Lowest height clogs on grass over 4 inches
- Battery voltage lower than some 40V competitors
5. American Lawn Mower Company 51319
The American Lawn Mower Company 51319 is a 19-inch corded electric mower with a 13-amp motor — no battery to charge, no fuel to mix. It offers mulching and rear bagging options via a grass catcher and included mulch plug. The 3-position height adjustment ranges from 1 to 3 inches, covering basic seasonal settings.
Users highlight its lightweight construction (35.7 pounds) and quiet operation compared to gas rotary mowers. The cord requires management — a 50- or 100-foot extension cord is recommended for average lots — but the trade-off is unlimited runtime. Assembly is straightforward, and the plastic deck resists rust.
Reliability concerns appear: one owner reported smoke and fire after 15 seconds of use, though this appears to be an outlier. The height adjustment is limited to three positions, which feels basic compared to 7-position competitors. The corded design restricts mobility around trees and garden beds, making this best for small, open lawns with convenient outlet access.
What works
- Unlimited runtime — no battery limits
- Lightweight and easy to push
- Quieter than gas rotary mowers
What doesn’t
- Limited to cord length (needs extension cord)
- Only three height adjustment positions
- Rare but serious reliability issues reported
6. RB 9″ Mini Cordless Lawn Mower
The RB 9-inch cordless mower is purpose-built for tiny spaces — think 540 square feet or less. It weighs just 11.5 pounds (without battery) and features a 6,000 RPM brushless motor for fine mulching. The pivoting front wheels and one-hand steering let you navigate tight corners and bumpy ground where a full-size reel mower struggles.
Users describe it as “vacuuming the yard” — lightweight enough for seniors, quiet enough for early morning mowing. The 3 cutting heights (1.2 to 2 inches) are limited but adequate for small lawns. The upright storage design saves significant garage space, and the detachable aluminum handle makes transport trivial.
Caveats: the 40V 2Ah battery provides only 25-30 minutes of runtime, which is fine for tiny lawns but not much more. There’s no grass bag — clippings collect under the housing and must be cleaned out with the included scoop. The plastic build feels somewhat flimsy, and long-term durability is unproven. For balconies, patches, or tight garden strips, it’s a uniquely practical tool.
What works
- Extremely lightweight and easy to carry
- One-hand steering for tight corners
- Compact upright storage saves space
What doesn’t
- Short runtime — 25-30 minutes per charge
- No grass bag; clippings collect under deck
- Plastic build feels less durable
7. Scotts 2000-20S Classic Push Reel Mower
The Scotts 2000-20S is the classic 20-inch, 5-blade manual reel mower — no motor, no battery, just pure mechanical efficiency. The ball-bearing reel runs on composite wheels with a 10-inch diameter, reducing rolling resistance. The quick-snap height adjustment (1 to 3 inches) is tool-less and fast.
Owners praise its lightweight 26.9-pound build and the clean scissor cut it delivers on regularly mowed lawns. Assembly is tool-less and takes under 15 minutes. The heat-treated alloy steel blades hold their edge longer than untreated steel, and the cushioned handle reduces hand fatigue during longer mowing sessions.
Limitations: the 5-blade reel leaves a rougher cut on thick grass compared to 7-blade variants. There’s no grass catcher, so clippings are left on the lawn (which acts as natural fertilizer). Small twigs and debris can jam the reel instantly, requiring a clear yard before mowing. Best for flat lawns under 5,000 square feet where weekly mowing keeps grass short.
What works
- Lightweight and easy to maneuver
- Tool-less height adjustment
- Heat-treated alloy steel blades
What doesn’t
- 5-blade reel struggles on thick grass
- No grass catcher included
- Jams easily on small twigs and debris
8. Scotts 716-18S 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
The Scotts 716-18S upgrades to a 7-blade reel on an 18-inch deck, delivering a noticeably finer cut than 5-blade alternatives. The 10-inch dual tracking wheels and ball-bearing reel reduce push effort despite the extra blades. Height adjusts from 1 to 3 inches, and the cushioned grip handle provides comfortable two-handed control.
Users report that the 7-blade design handles Bermuda and thick St. Augustine better than the 5-blade Scotts 2000-20S. The 25.6-pound weight makes it easy to tilt for edge trimming or carry up steps. The heat-treated alloy steel blades hold sharpness well through a season of weekly mowing.
Cons: the foam handle grip can disintegrate after a season in the sun. The mower still jams on sticks and debris — no reel mower is immune. The 18-inch width means more passes on larger lawns. Owners recommend oiling the blades after each use and storing dry to prevent rust. A strong mid-range manual option for those who want a cleaner cut without moving to a cordless motor.
What works
- 7-blade reel provides finer, cleaner cut
- Lightweight at 25.6 pounds
- Ball-bearing reel reduces push effort
What doesn’t
- Foam handle grip degrades over time
- 18-inch width requires more passes
- Still jams on sticks and yard debris
9. American Lawn Mower 1804-18
The American Lawn Mower Company 1804-18 is an 18-inch, 5-blade manual reel mower that includes a grass catcher — a rarity at this entry-level price. The 7-position height adjustment ranges from 0.5 to 2.75 inches, offering the lowest minimum height in the manual group for tight warm-season cuts. The ergonomic U-style handle reduces wrist strain during longer mows.
Users find it lightweight (27.3 pounds), sharp out of the box, and easy to assemble in under 10 minutes. The grass catcher snaps onto the back and collects about 50% of clippings — better than nothing but prone to falling off when backing up. The red steel frame looks classic and resists rust with basic care.
Drawbacks: the grass catcher is flimsy and often requires modification (bungee cords or zip ties) to stay attached. The mower throws clippings to the left, so mowing clockwise helps keep the lawn tidy. Tall grass and uneven ground choke the 5-blade reel quickly. This is a budget-friendly starting point for small, flat lawns where you can mow weekly and accept a semi-functional catcher.
What works
- Includes grass catcher for clipping collection
- Lowest minimum height at 0.5 inches
- Sharp blades out of the box
What doesn’t
- Grass catcher falls off easily
- 5-blade reel struggles on tall grass
- Catcher only collects ~50% of clippings
Hardware & Specs Guide
Reel Blade Count
A 5-blade reel is standard for small lawns and thin grass. A 7-blade reel cuts finer and handles thick grass better but increases push effort on manual models. Motorized cordless reels can use higher blade counts without added drag because the motor drives the reel independently.
Cutting Width vs Lawn Size
Every inch of cutting width saves roughly 50 feet of walking per 1,000 square feet. An 18-inch mower on a 5,000-square-foot lawn requires about 3,300 linear feet of passes. A 21-inch mower cuts that to roughly 2,850 feet — a 15% time savings. Match width to your gate openings as well.
Battery Voltage & Amp-Hours
Higher voltage (56V, 80V) generally means more torque for thick grass. Amp-hours (Ah) indicate runtime — a 6.0Ah battery typically lasts 45-60 minutes on a cordless reel mower. Two batteries double your effective mowing window. Lower voltage 40V systems are adequate for small-to-medium lawns with regular mowing.
Self-Propel vs Manual Push
Self-propel mowers use a drive motor to move the wheels, reducing push effort to near zero on flat ground. Manual push mowers rely entirely on your walking motion to spin the reel and move the wheels. Self-propel adds weight (15-30 pounds) and cost but is essential for slopes or large lawns.
FAQ
Is a 7-blade reel always better than a 5-blade reel?
Can an electric reel mower handle wet grass?
How often should I sharpen the blades on a reel mower?
Do I need a self-propel model if my lawn has a slope?
Will a reel mower cut weeds or tall grass?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most gardeners seeking the best electric reel mower, the winner is the EGO POWER+ LM2114SP because it delivers gas-beating torque, a reliable self-propel system, and excellent build quality that cuts through thick grass without stalling. If you want a lightweight cordless option with included spare batteries for extended runtime, grab the Wild Badger Power 40V. And for small, flat lawns on a budget where a simple manual reel is all you need, nothing beats the value of the Scotts 716-18S 7-Blade for its fine scissor cut at a light weight.