The scraping sound of a weed whacker and the smell of gasoline exhaust may be the default Saturday morning soundtrack for most neighborhoods, but a growing number of lawn owners are trading that noise for the gentle whir of steel on steel. A reel mower delivers a scissor-like cut that shears the grass blade cleanly rather than tearing it, which reduces stress on the turf and leaves a healthier, greener lawn with a finer texture. The catch, however, is that not all reel mowers deliver the same precision, and sifting through hundreds of reviews to find the one that actually holds its edge and rolls smoothly over uneven ground takes real effort.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind Gardening Beyond. I spend my time comparing specifications, studying horticultural data, and analyzing aggregated owner feedback to understand exactly what separates a good mowing experience from a frustrating one.
Whether you are working with a small suburban patch or a slightly larger plot you want to keep pristine, the best highest rated reel mowers share a common set of traits: durable alloy-steel blades, a cutting width that matches the size of your lawn, and height adjustments that let you adapt to seasonal grass growth patterns.
How To Choose The Best Highest Rated Reel Mowers
A reel mower looks deceptively simple — a spinning cylinder of blades against a stationary bedknife — but the details in the build determine whether you get a clean, effortless cut or a mower that skips, jams, and dulls after three uses. Here is what to look at before you buy.
Cutting Width and Your Lawn Size
The cutting width directly affects how many back-and-forth passes you make. A 14-inch mower is fine for very small lawns under 2,000 square feet, but it doubles your walk time compared to a 20-inch model. For a quarter-acre lot, a 20-inch or wider mower saves significant time without adding enough weight to make pushing difficult on flat ground.
Blade Count and Cut Quality
More blades — 7 versus 5 — produce a finer, more uniform cut because the reel rotates more times per foot of forward travel. The trade-off is higher rolling resistance: a 7-blade mower requires slightly more effort to push through thick grass. If you mow weekly and keep the grass short, a 5-blade mower works perfectly. If you let the lawn grow a bit longer between cuts, the extra blades help prevent tearing.
Height Adjustment Range
A wide height range gives you flexibility across the growing season. Most reel mowers adjust between about half an inch on the low end up to 3 inches on the high end. Cooling spring grass does best at the taller setting to protect the root zone, while mid-summer Bermuda or zoysia can be cut shorter. Look for quick-snap or lever adjustments — tools are annoying to carry to the yard.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scotts 2000-20S | Premium | Large flat lawns | 20-inch cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
| Scotts 716-18S | Premium | Finer cut quality | 18-inch cut / 7 blades | Amazon |
| Gardena Comfort 330 | Premium | Precision English lawn | 33 cm cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
| LawnMaster LMRM2001 | Mid-Range | Adjustability depth | 20-inch cut / 9 positions | Amazon |
| Great States 815-18 | Mid-Range | Budget-friendly 18-inch | 18-inch cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
| Craftsman 304-14CR | Mid-Range | Compact yards | 14-inch cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
| Goplus 18-Inch | Mid-Range | Easy storage | 18-inch cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
| American Lawn 1204-14 | Budget | Lightweight entry | 14-inch cut / 4 blades | Amazon |
| Goplus 14-Inch | Budget | Very small lawns | 14-inch cut / 5 blades | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
8. Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2000-20S
The Scotts 2000-20S is the standard against which other reel mowers are measured, and for good reason. Its 20-inch cutting width is the widest in this list, which means you cover more ground with fewer passes. The 5-blade ball-bearing reel rolls smoothly, and the heat-treated alloy steel blades hold their edge far longer than the stamped steel you find on entry-level models. The 10-inch dual tracking wheels also keep the mower tracking straight, so you do not fight the steering on every row.
The quick-snap height adjustment lets you move between 1 inch and 3 inches in seconds without tools. That flexibility is critical when you want to raise the cut in early spring to let the grass establish a deep root system and then lower it in summer for a tighter appearance. The cushioned grip handle reduces vibration, and the entire mower assembles without tools, which removes a major frustration point.
At 26.9 pounds, it is not the lightest unit you can buy, but the weight gives it stability; the mower does not bounce or hop over small bumps the way ultralight models do. Owners consistently report that the reel stays aligned for years, and the bedknife can be adjusted with a simple turn of the bolts to maintain that scissor-like contact. For anyone with a flat lawn of 5,000 square feet or more, this is the most efficient reel mower you can own.
What works
- Widest cutting path on the list reduces mowing time significantly
- Ball-bearing reel rolls with low friction even on warm days
- Tool-less height adjustment covers a wide 1-inch to 3-inch range
What doesn’t
- Heavier than smaller 14-inch models at nearly 27 pounds
- No grass catcher included for clipping collection
7. Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 716-18S
The Scotts 716-18S takes the same build philosophy as the 2000-20S but adds two more blades for a noticeably finer finish. With 7 blades on an 18-inch reel, the cylinder rotates more times per foot of travel, which translates to a smoother, more manicured cut that approaches the look of a cylinder mower on a golf course. The heat-treated alloy steel stays sharp season after season, and the ball-bearing reel keeps the rolling resistance low despite the extra blades.
The height adjustment ranges from 1 inch to 3 inches with a quick-snap mechanism that does not require tools. The 10-inch dual tracking wheels give the mower a stable feel even when you push at a brisk walking pace. The cushioned grip on the handle reduces hand fatigue, and the mower is easy to maneuver around flower beds and trees because of the 18-inch width.
One practical consideration: the 7-blade reel requires slightly more effort to push through thick or tall grass compared to a 5-blade unit. That is a trade-off worth making if you prioritize cut quality and mow weekly. If you let the lawn go longer between cuts, you will want to take lighter passes. Owners consistently praise the cut finish and report that the reel stays true out of the box with minimal adjustment needed.
What works
- Seven blades deliver a finer, almost golf-green quality cut
- Heat-treated alloy steel blades resist dulling through entire seasons
- Quick-snap height adjustment is simple and reliable
What doesn’t
- Requires more push effort through tall or dense grass
- No grass catcher available for this model
9. Gardena Manual Push Lawnmower Comfort 330
The Gardena Comfort 330 is a different breed of reel mower, built with German engineering that prioritizes frictionless operation and a true English-lawn finish. The 5-blade cylinder uses a scissor-like cutting action that slices the grass rather than tearing it, and the blades are pre-set from the factory so you do not have to fiddle with the reel-to-bedknife gap before your first mow. The cutting width is 33 centimeters, which translates to roughly 13 inches — narrower than most budget models — but the precision of the cut is unmatched in this price tier.
The large wheels and lightweight construction make the mower easy to push, and the wheel profile is designed to maintain traction even on damp grass, which is a real advantage if you live in a climate with morning dew. The height adjustment ranges from 12 mm to 42 mm, giving you a decent range for different grass types, though the top end is lower than what American-style reel mowers offer. This mower is intended for lawns up to about 150 square meters, so it is best suited to small, well-maintained turf.
The Comfort 330 qualifies for a 10-year warranty after registration, which signals a level of build confidence that few other manual mowers match. The plastic and metal construction is corrosion-resistant, and the blades are designed to never touch each other, so they maintain their sharpness during cutting. Owners report that the mower rolls effortlessly and produces a clean, striped finish that draws compliments from neighbors.
What works
- Factory pre-set blades require zero initial adjustment
- Large wheels roll easily on wet grass without slipping
- 10-year warranty after registration shows long-term reliability
What doesn’t
- Narrow 33 cm cutting width means more passes on larger lawns
- Maximum cutting height of 42 mm is lower than some competitors offer
5. LawnMaster LMRM2001
The LawnMaster LMRM2001 brings a 20-inch cutting width together with a category-leading 9 height adjustment positions that span from 1.3 inches to 2.6 inches. That range of adjustability is rare among reel mowers, where you commonly see only 3 or 4 positions. The 5-blade reel is made of durable steel, and the motorless design means zero fuel costs and virtually no maintenance beyond keeping the blades clean and occasionally lubricating the bearings.
The 10-inch front wheels give the mower good maneuverability, and the orange steel-and-plastic frame feels solid without being overly heavy. The scissor-like cutting action is effective on Bermuda, fescue, and ryegrass as long as you keep the lawn at a moderate height. Owners appreciate the wide range of cutting heights because it lets them adjust for seasonal growth patterns without needing to swap tools.
One distinguishing feature is the sheer number of height settings: 9 micro-adjustments mean you can dial in exactly the cut length you want rather than settling for the closest preset. The trade-off is that the adjustment mechanism requires a bit more effort to change compared to a quick-snap lever. Still, for the combination of width and fine-tuning capability, the LMRM2001 is a strong mid-range pick.
What works
- Nine height positions provide more cut-length precision than any competitor
- 20-inch width minimizes passes on medium to large lawns
- Motorless design eliminates fuel and noise concerns
What doesn’t
- Height adjustment mechanism is not as quick as quick-snap levers
- No grass catcher included for clipping collection
4. Great States 815-18
The Great States 815-18 is a no-nonsense reel mower that has been a staple of the category for years. It offers an 18-inch cutting width with 5 blades made from high-quality alloy steel, and the ball-bearing reel ensures smooth rolling even when you push at a steady pace. The height adjustment ranges from half an inch at the low end to 2.75 inches, which covers most common lawn care needs from a tight summer cut to a slightly higher spring setting.
The 10-inch composite wheels are durable and roll well over level ground, and the loop-style handle with cushioned grips gives you two comfortable hand positions. Assembly does not require special tools, and the mower is light enough at 27 pounds to lift and carry to a storage spot. The motorless design means no gas, no oil, and no extension cord — just push and cut.
Owners consistently note that the reel stays aligned well and that the cut quality is clean and even as long as you do not let the grass exceed 4 inches. The 2-year limited warranty adds a layer of confidence that some budget mowers lack. For the price, you get a well-rounded reel mower that does not cut corners on the blade steel or bearing quality.
What works
- Alloy steel blades hold an edge longer than ordinary steel
- Ball-bearing reel rolls smoothly with minimal resistance
- Height adjustment spans a useful 0.5-inch to 2.75-inch range
What doesn’t
- No grass catcher included with the mower
- Does not handle tall or overgrown grass well
6. Craftsman 304-14CR
The Craftsman 304-14CR is a compact 14-inch reel mower that pairs a 5-blade cutting reel with a grass catcher, making it a strong choice for small urban lawns where clipping collection matters. The steel blades are built to stay sharp for years, and the T-style handle with cushioned grips gives you good control. The height adjusts from half an inch to 1.75 inches, which is a narrower range than some competitors but still covers the most common cutting heights for well-maintained turf.
The included grass catcher is a real plus for reel mowers, where the clippings often fall directly onto the lawn because the scissor action does not generate enough velocity to throw them into a bag. The catcher installs and removes without tools, and you can also run the mower without the bag if you want the clippings to mulch back into the soil. The 8.5-inch front wheels and rear roller bar help the mower track straight.
Owners often mention that the Craftsman is easy to assemble right out of the box and that the cut quality is clean on short to moderate grass. The 18-pound weight makes it one of the lightest models in this roundup, which is helpful if you need to carry it up steps or store it on a wall hook. Just keep in mind that the 14-inch width means more passes on anything larger than a 2,000-square-foot lawn.
What works
- Grass catcher included and works well for clipping collection
- Lightweight at 18 pounds, easy to carry and store
- Tool-less assembly gets you mowing fast
What doesn’t
- Narrow 14-inch width requires many passes on larger lawns
- Height range tops out at only 1.75 inches
3. Goplus 18 Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower
The Goplus 18-inch reel mower brings a 5-blade manganese steel cutting system to a mid-range price point, and the manganese steel formulation is worth noting because it offers superior impact resistance compared to standard alloy steel. The 18-inch cutting path covers small to medium yards efficiently, and the 4-position height adjustment ranges from 1.06 inches to 2 inches — a modest range but adequate for most seasonal changes if you mow frequently.
The detachable grass catcher is a practical addition for those who want to collect clippings for composting or disposal, and the bag is easy to remove and empty without making a mess. When the bag is off, the mower mulches the clippings back into the lawn, which returns nitrogen to the soil. The anti-slip wheels and foam-padded handle reduce fatigue during longer mowing sessions, and the mower folds upright for compact storage against a wall.
Owners highlight the quiet operation and the fact that the blades rinse clean with a garden hose after use. The Goplus is also one of the few mid-range models that includes both a grass catcher and a foldable storage design, making it a practical choice for homeowners with limited shed space. Keep the grass shorter than 4 inches for best results, as the mower struggles with overgrowth like most reel mowers.
What works
- Manganese steel blades offer excellent durability and impact resistance
- Foldable upright design saves storage space in small garages
- Grass catcher included for clipping collection
What doesn’t
- Height adjustment range is narrower than some 18-inch competitors
- Not ideal for grass taller than 4 inches
2. American Lawn Mower Company 1204-14
The American Lawn Mower Company 1204-14 is one of the lightest reel mowers on the market at only 19 pounds, and its simplicity is its greatest strength. The 4-blade reel cuts a 14-inch path, and the polymer wheels are durable while keeping the weight down. The height adjusts from 0.5 inches to 1.75 inches, which is on the lower side but works well for Bermuda, zoysia, and other warm-season grasses that prefer shorter cuts.
The steel blades are made from alloy steel and do a clean job on grass up to 4 inches tall. The mower is designed for small lawns, and the lightweight frame makes it easy to push and maneuver around tight corners. The red paint and classic reel-mower silhouette give it a nostalgic look that some buyers appreciate. Assembly is straightforward and does not require any special tools.
Owners consistently mention that the mower requires very little maintenance and that the cut quality is surprisingly good for a 4-blade unit as long as you stay on a weekly mowing schedule. The low height range means it is not ideal for cool-season grasses like tall fescue that thrive at 3 inches or higher. If you have a very small lawn and want a no-fuss mower that you can lift with one hand, this is a solid budget-friendly option.
What works
- Extremely lightweight at 19 pounds, easy to carry and store
- Alloy steel blades provide clean cuts on short grass
- Simple, low-maintenance design with durable polymer wheels
What doesn’t
- Only 4 blades produce a slightly coarser cut than 5-blade models
- Maximum cutting height of 1.75 inches is too low for some grass types
1. Goplus Manual Lawn Mower 14 Inch
The Goplus 14-inch manual mower offers a 5-blade manganese steel cutting system at an entry-level price point, making it one of the most affordable ways to get a scissor-like cut without power equipment. The cutting width is 14 inches, and the height adjusts through 4 positions from 1.06 inches to 2 inches. The included 7-gallon removable grass bag collects clippings as you mow, and the bag can be detached if you prefer to leave the clippings as mulch.
The 10-inch wheels feature a non-slip tread pattern that provides steady rolling on level ground, and the foam-padded handle reduces vibration during use. The mower folds upright for space-saving storage, and the vertical lock engages with an audible click so you know it is secure. The manganese steel blades are tougher than standard steel and resist chipping if you hit a small rock or twig.
Owners note that the mower is effective on short grass and that the grass bag catches most clippings without clogging. The build quality feels appropriate for the price, and the mower is light enough at 21.6 pounds to carry to a shed or garage. It performs best on lawns that are mowed at least once a week, and it struggles if the grass exceeds 4 inches in height. For a budget-friendly starter mower, the Goplus delivers the essential features without unnecessary complexity.
What works
- Five manganese steel blades cut cleaner than budget 4-blade alternatives
- 7-gallon grass bag collects clippings effectively
- Folds upright for compact storage with locking mechanism
What doesn’t
- Narrow 14-inch width is slow on lawns larger than 2,000 square feet
- Height adjustment is limited to 2 inches maximum
Hardware & Specs Guide
Reel and Bedknife Clearance
The gap between the reel blades and the stationary bedknife is measured in thousandths of an inch. A factory-set clearance of 0.003 to 0.005 inches gives the best scissor-like cut. A gap that is too wide lets grass slip through uncut; a gap that is too tight creates drag and wears the blades faster. Higher-rated models often come with adjustable eccentric bolts that let you fine-tune this clearance as the blades wear down over multiple seasons.
Blade Count vs. Rolling Resistance
More blades (7 vs. 5) produce a finer cut because the reel rotates more times per inch of forward travel, but the additional blades also increase the friction between the reel and the bedknife. This translates to higher rolling resistance, which means you have to push harder. For lawns of 4,000 square feet or less, the extra effort from a 7-blade mower is negligible. For larger or slightly sloped lawns, a 5-blade mower is easier to push while still delivering a good cut.
FAQ
Will a reel mower cut grass that is 6 inches tall?
How do I adjust the blades on a reel mower?
Can a reel mower mulches grass clippings effectively?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most gardeners who want the widest path and the longest blade life, the best highest rated reel mowers winner is the Scotts 2000-20S because its 20-inch cutting width, ball-bearing reel, and tool-less height adjustment make it the most efficient reel mower for medium to large flat lawns. If you want the finest possible cut quality with 7 blades, grab the Scotts 716-18S. And for a precision-engineered cylinder mower that produces an English-lawn finish on small turf, nothing beats the Gardena Comfort 330.